
544
THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NUTRITION
[\‘ol. 6, No. 5
fore, one must assumne that a 1)atient will not
lose, or conversely, gain a ])0U11(l of actual body
tissue unless he receives at least I , 500 cal less or
more food than he requires for his standard
metabolic need, computed for rest and exer-
cise.”
In his conclusions Joslin makes the error of
failing to differentiate between the metabolism
of the individual who is on a low-calorie diet
but who is in protein and carbohydrate (glyco-
gen) equilibrium, and one who is fasting and
has marked protein and glycogen deficits. The
significance of this point is strikingly demon-
strated in Benedict’s observation.
Benedict’s subject fasted for 31 days, par-
taking only of distilled water. The pertinent
findings are best expressed in Benedict’s own
words.’2 “During the 31-day fast this sub-
ject actually excreted 277.32 g of nitrogen in
the urine, thus averaging 8.95 g of nitrogen per
day. This would correspond to 1,664 g (3.7
lb) of protein or 8,319 g (18.3 lb) of flesh. Since
the entire loss of body weight of this subject
was 13.25 kg (30 lb), it can be seen that 63 per
cent of the total loss may be accounted in flesh
catabolized.’ ‘ Study of Table 63, page 412,12
shows that whereas during the 31-day fast, the
amount of water lost concomitantly from the
catabolism of flesh, was enormous (6,383 ml or
14 lb) ; the amount lost concomitantly from
the catabolism of fat was negligible (367 ml or
0.8 lb). The catabolism of 1,664 g of protein
which resulted in a loss of 18.3 pound of body
weight, yielded only 6,828 cal. If the fasting
subject had been in protein and carbohydrate
equilibrium the 6,828 calories would have been
derived from adipose tissue with a loss of only
1.82 pound (0.83 kg). The categoric conclusion
can be drawn that the caloric equivalent of one
pound of body weight lost when an individual
is fasting, is markedly less than when he is on a
low-calorie diet, but in protein and carbohy-
cirate equilibrium.
Clinical observations confirm the error in
Joslin’s thesis. If a person who requires 2,500
cal/day to maintain caloric equilibrium is on a
daily diet containing 1,000 cal, he will give a
daily deficit of 1,500 cal or a weekly deficit of
10,500 cal. According to Joslin, such a per-
son should lose 7 pounds of body weight per
week. From practical experience we know
that this does not occur. In Strang’s3 pa-
tients the loss of 0.6 pound of body weight day
resulted fromn a deficit of 2, 100 cal. If Jos-
lin’s figure of I ,500 cal for the caloric equivalent
of one pound of body weight lost were accepted,
they should have lost 1 .4 pounds instead of 0.6
pound actually lost.
Utilizing indirect methods for the estimation
of body composition Keys et a!.6 in a study of
individuals who had not previously fasted,
found that on a high calorie diet the caloric
equivalent of 1 kg of the tissue mass gained was
6, 180 cal. They also found that the character
of the tissue mass gained in rehabilitation by
previously starved men was quite different
from that gained by well-fed men who simply
ate to excess. Whereas, about two-thirds of
the weight gain of the latter was pure fat, in
the starved men the gain in early rehabilitation
was made up of only 10 to 20 per cent fat.
DISCUSSION
Certain definite conclusions may be made
from the observations and studies described
above. The average obese individual who is
placed on a low-calorie diet for the purpose of
weight reduction, is practically in protein and
carbohydrate (glycogen) equilibrium. The ca-
boric deficit in these patients is made up almost
entirely by the catabolism of fat. The theo-
retical value of one pound (454 g) of adipose tis-
sue is 3,750 ‘ In clinical studies by Strang
et a!.’ on weight reduction on obese individuals
who were on a low-calorie diet a value of 3,500
cab was obtained for each pound of body weight
lost. The conclusion can be drawn that 3,500
is the caloric value of one pound of body
weight lost.
It must be stressed that it is fundamental
that the protein content of the low-calorie diets
employed in weight reduction be kept high.
If they are so low as to permit appreciable
negative nitrogen balances, there will be con-
siderable loss of water. This will result in a
decrease in the caloric equivalent of 1 lb of
body weight lost and consequently a more rapid
rate of loss in weight. This, is, however, a
spurious loss because it has no permanency.
After the desired weight loss has occurred and
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-abstract/6/5/542/4729975
by Washington University in St. Louis user
on 09 April 2018