Graphical Methods in the thermodynamics of fluids

By Josiah Willard Gibbs

Annotated on Fermat's Library with 0 comments. Text and annotations as Markdown Original paper

GRAPHICAL METHODS IN THE
THERMODYNAMICS OF FLUIDS
Josiah Willard Gibbs
Transactions of the Connecticut Academy, II. pp. 309-342,
April-May, 1873.
Typeset by
W. Craig Carter and Michael A. Gibson
Department of Materials Science and Engineering
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
ALTHOUGH geometrical representations of propositions in the thermodynamics of flu-
ids are in general use, and have done good service in disseminating clear notions in this
science, yet they have by no means received the extension in respect to variety and gener-
ality of which they are capable. So far as regards a general graphical method, which can
exhibit at once all the thermodynamic properties of a fluid concerned in reversible processes,
and serve alike for the demonstration of general theorems and the numerical solution of
particular problems, it is the general if not the universal practice to use diagrams in which
the rectilinear co-ordinates represent volume and pressure. The object of this article is to
call attention to certain diagrams of different construction, which afford graphical methods
coextensive in their applications with that in ordinary use, and preferable to it in many cases
in respect of distinctness or of convenience.
1 Quantities and Relations which are to be represented
by the Diagram.
We have to consider the following quantities:—
v, the volume,
p, the pressure,
t, the (absolute) temperature,
e, the energy,
I, the entropy,
of a given body in any state,
also W, the work done,
1
and H, the heat received,
)
by the body in passing from one state to another
These are subject to the relations expressed by the following differential equations:—
dW = αp dv, (a)
d = β dH − dW, (b)
dη =
dH
2
t
, (c)
1
Work spent upon the body is as usual to be considered as a negative quantity of work done by the body,
and heat given out by the body as a negative quantity of heat received by it.
It is taken for granted that the body has a uniform temperature throughout, and that the pressure (or
expansive force) has a uniform value both for all points in the body and for all directions. This, it will be
observed, will exclude irreversible processes, but will not entirely exclude solids, although the condition of
equal pressure in all directions renders the case very limited, in which they come within the scope of the
discussion.
2
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
where α and β are constants depending upon the units by which v, p, W and H are
measured. We may suppose our units so chosen that α = 1 and β = 1,
3
and write our
equations in the simpler form,
d = dH − dW, (1)
dW = p dv, (2)
dH = t dη. (3)
Eliminating dW and dH, we have
d = t dη − p dv.
(4)
The quantities v, p, t, and η are determined when the state of the body is given, and it
may be permitted to call them functions of the state of the body. The state of a body, in the
sense in which the term is used in the thermodynamics of fluids, is capable of two independent
variations, so that between the five quantities v, p, t, and η there exist relations expressible
by three finite equations, different in general for different substances, but always such as to
be in harmony with the differential equation (4). This equation evidently signifies that if
be expressed as function of v and η, the partial differential co-efficients of this function taken
with respect to v and to η will be equal to −p and to t respectively.
4
On the other hand W and H are not functions of the state of the body (or functions
of any of the quantities v, p, t, and η), but are determined by the whole series of states
through which the body is supposed to pass.
2
Equation (a) may be derived from simple mechanical considerations. Equations (b) and (c) may be
considered as defining the energy and entropy of any state of the body, or more strictly as defining the
differentials d and dη. That functions of the state of the body exist, the differentials of which satisfy these
equations, may easily be deduced from the first and second laws of thermodynamics. The term entropy, it
will be observed, is here used in accordance with the original suggestion of Clausius, and not in the sense
in which it has been employed by Professor Tait and others after his suggestion. The same quantity has
been called by Professor Rankine the Thermodynamic function. See Clausius, Mechanische Wärmetheorie,
Abhnd. ix. § 14; or Pogg. Ann., Bd. cxxv. (1865), p. 390; and Rankine, Phil. Trans., vol. 144, p. 126.
3
For example, we may choose as the unit of volume, the cube of the unit of length,—as the unit of pressure
the unit of force acting upon the square of the unit of length,—as the unit of work the unit of force acting
through the unit of length,—and as the unit of heat the thermal equivalent of the unit of work. The units
of length and of force would still be arbitrary as well as the unit of temperature.
4
An equation giving in terms of η and v, or more generally any finite equation between , η, and v for a
definite quantity of any fluid, may be considered as the fundamental thermodynamic equation of that fluid,
as from it by aid of equations (2), (3) and (4) may be derived all the thermodynamic properties of the fluid
(so far as reversible processes are concerned), viz.: the fundamental equation with equation (4) gives the
three relations existing between v, p, t, and η, and these relations being known, equations (2) and (3) give
the work W and heat H for any change of state of the fluid.
3
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
2 Fundamental Idea and General Properties of the Di-
agram.
Now if we associate a particular point in a plane with every separate state, of which the body
is capable, in any continuous manner, so that states differing infinitely little are associated
with points which are infinitely near to each other,
5
the points associated with states of
equal volume will form lines, which may be called lines of equal volume, the different lines
being distinguished by the numerical value of the volume (as lines of volume 10, 20, 30, etc.).
In the same way we may conceive of lines of equal pressure, of equal temnperature, of equal
energy, and of equal entropy. These lines we may also call isometric, isopiestic, isothermal,
isodynamrnic, isentropic,
6
and if necessary use these words as substantives.
Suppose the body to change its state, the points associated with the states through
which the body passes will form a line, which we may call the path of the body. The
conception of a path must include the idea of direction, to express the order in which the
body passes through the series of states. With every such change of state there is connected
in general a certain amount of work done, W , and of heat received, H, which we may call
the work and the heat of the path.
7
The value of these quantities may be calculated from
equations (2) and (3),
dW = p dv,
dH = t dη,
i.e., W =
Z
p dv, (5)
W =
Z
t dη, (6)
the integration being carried on from the beginning to the end of the path. If the direction
of the path is reversed, W and H change their signs, remaining the same in absolute value.
If the changes of state of the body form a cycle, i.e., if the final state is the same as the
initial, the path becomes a circuit, and the work done and heat received are equal, as may
be seen from equation (1), which when integrated for this case becomes 0 = H − W .
5
The method usually employed in treatises on thermodynamics, in which the rectangular co-ordinates
of the point are made proportional to the volume and pressure of the body, is a single example of such an
association.
6
These lines are usually known by the name given them by Rankine, adiabatic. If, however, we follow the
suggestion of Clausius and call that quantity entropy, which Rankine called the termodynacmic f2nmction, it
seems natural to go one step farther, and call the lines in which this quantity has a constant value isentropic.
7
For the sake of brevity, it will be convenient to use language which attributes to the diagram properties
which belong to the associated states of the body. Thus it can give rise to no ambiguity, if we speak of the
volume or the temperature of a point in the diagram, or of the work or heat of a line, instead of the volume
or temperature of the body in the state associated with the point, or the work done or the heat received
by the body in passing through the states associated with the points of the line. In like manner also we
may speak of the body moving along a line in the diagram, instead of passing through the series of states
represented by the line.
4
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
The circuit will enclose a certain area, which we may consider as positive or negative
according to the direction of the circuit which circumscribes it. The direction in which areas
must be circumscribed in order that their value may be positive, is of course arbitrary. In
other words, if x and y are the rectangular co-ordinates, we may define an area either as
R
y dx, or as
R
x dy.
If an area be divided into any number of parts, the work done in the circuit bounding
the whole area is equal to the sum of the work done in all the circuits bounding the partial
areas. This is evident from the consideration, that the work done in each of the lines which
separate the partial areas appears twice and with contrary signs in the sum of the work done
in the circuits bounding the partial areas. Also the heat received in the circuit bounding the
whole area is equal to the sum of the heat received in all the circuits bounding the partial
areas.
8
Figure 1
If all the dimensions of a circuit are infinitely small, the ratio of the included area to the
work or heat of the circuit is independent of the shape of the circuit and the direction in which
it is described, and varies only with its position in the diagram. That this ratio is independent
of the direction in which the circuit is described, is evident from the consideration that a
reversal of this direction simply changes the sign of both terms of the ratio. To prove that the
ratio is independent of the shape of the circuit let us suppose the area ABCDE (Figure 1)
divided up by an infinite number of isometrics v
1
v
1
, v
2
v
2
, etc., with equal differences of
volume dv, and an infinite number of isopiestics p
1
p
1
, p
2
p
2
, etc., with equal differences of
pressure dp. Now from the principle of continuity, as the whole figure is infinitely small, the
ratio of the area of one of the small quadrilaterals into which the figure is divided to the
work done in passing around it is approximately the same for all the different quadrilaterals.
Therefore the area of the figure composed of all the complete quadrilaterals which fall within
the given circuit has to the work done in circumscribing this figure the same ratio, which
we will call γ. But the area of this figure is approximately the same as that of the given
circuit, and the work done in describing this figure is approximately the same as that done
in describing the given circuit (eq. 5). Therefore the area of the given circuit has to the
8
The conception of areas as positive or negative renders it unnecessary in propositions of this kind to
state explicitly the direction in which the circuits are to be described. For the directions of the circuits are
determined by the signs of the areas, and the signs of the partial areas must be the same as that of the area
out of which they were formed.
5
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
work done or heat received in that circuit this ratio γ, which is independent of the shape of
the circuit.
Now if we imagine the systems of equidifferent isometrics and isopiestics, which have
just been spoken of, extended over the whole diagram, the work done in circumscribing one
of the small quadrilaterals, so that the increase of pressure directly precedes the increase
of volume, will have in every part of the diagram a constant value, viz., the product of the
differences of volume and pressure (dv × dp), as may easily be proved by applying equation
(2) successively to its four sides. But the area of one of these quadrilaterals, which we could
consider as constant within the limits of the infinitely small circuit, may vary for different
parts of the diagram, and will indicate proportionally the value of γ, which is equal to the
area divided by dv × dp.
In like manner, if we imagine systems of isentropics and isothermals drawn throughout
the diagram for equal differences dη and dt, the heat received in passing around one of the
small quadrilaterals, so that the increase of t shall directly precede that of η, will be the
constant product dl × dt, as may be proved by equation (3), and the value of γ, which is
equal to the area divided by the heat, will be indicated proportionally by the areas.
9
This
quantity γ, which is the ratio of the area of an infinitely small circuit to the work done or
heat received in that circuit, and which we may call the scale on which work and heat are
represented by areas, or more briefly, the scale of work and heat, may have a constant value
9
The indication of the value of γ by systems of equidifferent isometric and isopiestics, or isentropics and
isothermals, is explained above, because it seems in accordance with the spirit of the graphical method, and
because it avoids the extraneous consideration of the co-ordinates. If, however, it is desired to have analytical
expressions for the value of γ based upon the relations between the coordinates of the point and the state
of the body, it is easy to deduce such expressions as the following, in which x and y are the rectangular
co-ordinates, and it is supposed that the sign of an area is determined in accordance with the equation
A = f ydx:—
1
γ
=
dv
dx
·
dp
dy
−
dp
dx
·
dv
dy
=
dη
dx
·
dt
dy
−
dt
dx
·
dη
dy
,
where x and y are regarded as the independent variables;—or
γ =
dx
dv
·
dy
dp
−
dy
dv
·
dx
dp
,
here v and p are the independent variables;—or
γ =
dx
dη
·
dy
dt
−
dy
dη
·
dx
dt
,
where η and t are the independent variables;—or
1
γ
=
−
d
2
dv dη
dx
dv
·
dy
dη
−
dy
dv
·
dx
dη
,
where v and η are the independent variables.
These and similar expressions for
1
γ
may be found by dividing the value of the work or heat for an
infinitely small circuit by the area included. This operation can be most conveniently performed upon a
circuit consisting of four lines, in each of which one of the independent variables is constant. E.g., the last
formula can be most easily found from an infinitely small circuit formed of two isometrics and two isentropics.
6
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
throughout the diagram or it may have a varying value. The diagram in ordinary use affords
an example of the first case, as the area of a circuit is everywhere proportional to the work
or heat. There are other diagrams which have the same property, and we may call all such
diagrams of constant scale.
In any case we may consider the scale of work and heat as known for every point of the
diagram, so far as we are able to draw the isometrics and isopiestics or the isentropics and
isothermals. If we write δW and δH for the work and heat of an infinitesimal circuit, and
δA for the area included, the relations of these quantities are thus expressed:—
10
δW = δH =
1
γ
δA.
(7)
We may find the value of W and H for a circuit of finite dimensions by supposing the included
area A divided into areas δA infinitely small in all directions, for which therefore the above
equation will hold, and taking the sum of the values of δH or δW for the various areas δA.
Writing W
C
and H
C
for the work and heat of the circuit C, and
P
C
for a summation or
integration performed within the limits of this circuit, we have
W
C
= H
C
=
C
X
1
γ
δA (8)
We have thus an expression for the value of the work and heat of a circuit involving an
integration extending over an area instead of one extending over a line, as in equations (5)
and (6).
Similar expressions may be found for the work and the heat of a path which is not a
circuit. For this case may be reduced to the preceding by the consideration that W = O
for a path on an isometric or on the line of no pressure (eq. 2), and H = 0 for a path on
an isentropic or on the line of absolute cold. Hence the work of any path S is equal to that
of the circuit formed of S, the isometric of the final state, the line of no pressure and the
isometric of the initial state, which circuit may be represented by the notation [S, v
00
, p
0
, v
0
].
And the heat of the same path is the same as that of the circuit [S, η
00
, t
0
, η
0
]. Therefore
using W
S
and H
S
to denote the work and heat of any path S, we have
W
S
=
[S,v
00
,p
0
,v
0
]
X
1
γ
δA (9)
H
S
=
[S,η
00
,t
0
,η
0
]
X
1
γ
δA (10)
10
To avoid confusion, as dW and dH are generally used and are used elsewhere in this article to denote
the work and heat of an infinite short path, a slightly different notation, δW and δH, is here used to denote
the work and heat of an infinitely small circuit. So δA is used to denote an element of area which is infinitely
small in all directions, as the letter d would only imply that the element was infinitely small in one direction.
So also below, the integration or summation which extends to all the elements written with δ is denoted by
the character
P
, as the character
R
naturally refers to elements written with d.
7
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
where as before the limits of the integration are denoted by the expression occupying the
place of an index to the sign
P
.
11
These equations evidently include equation 8 as a particular
case.
It is easy to form a material conception of these relations. If we imagine, for example,
mass inherent in the plane of the diagram with a varying (superficial) density represented
by
1
γ
, then
P
1
γ
δA will evidently denote the mass of the part of the plane included within the
limits of integration, this mass being taken positively or negatively according to the direction
of the circuit.
Thus far we have made no supposition in regard to the nature of the law, by which
we associate the points of a plane with the states of the body, except a certain condition
of continuity. Whatever law we may adopt, we obtain a method of representation of the
thermodynamic properties of the body, in which the relations existing between the functions
of the state of the body are indicated by a net-work of lines, while the work done and the heat
received by the body when it changes its state are represented by integrals extending over
the elements of a line, and also by an integral extending over the elements of certain areas
in the diagram, or, if we choose to introduce such a consideration, by the mass belonging to
these areas.
The different diagrams which we obtain by different laws of association are all such as
may be obtained from one another by a process of deformation, and this consideration is
sufficient to demonstrate their properties from the well-known properties of the diagram in
which the volume and pressure are represented by rectangular coordinates. For the relations
indicated by the net-work of isometrics, isopiestics etc., are evidently not altered by defor-
mation of the surface upon which they are drawn, and if we conceive of mass as belonging
to the surface, the mass included within given lines will also not be affected by the process
of deformation. If, then, the surface upon which the ordinary diagram is drawn has the
uniform superficial density 1, so that the work and heat of a circuit, which are represented
in this diagram by the included area, shall also be represented by the mass included, this
latter relation will hold for any diagram formed from this by deformation of the surface on
which it is drawn.
11
A word should be said in regard to the sense in which the above propositions should be understood. If
beyond the limits, within which the relations of v, p, t, and η are known and which we may call the limits
of the known field, we continue the isometrics, isopiestics, &c., in any way we please, only subject to the
condition that the relations of v, p, t, and η shall be consistent with the equation d = t dη − p dv, then
in calculating the values of quantities W and H determined by the equations dW = p dv and dH = t dη for
paths or circuits in any part of the diagram thus extended, we may use any of the propositions or processes
given above, as these three equations have formed the only basis of the reasoning. We will thus obtain values
of W and H, which will be identical with those which would be obtained by the immediate application of
the equations dW = p dv and dH = t dη to the path in question, and which in the case of any path which is
entirely contained in the known field will be the true values of the work and heat for the change of state of
the body which the path represents. We may thus use lines outside of the known field without attributing
to them any physical signification whatever, without considering the points in the lines as representing any
states of the body. If however, to fix our ideas, we choose to conceive of this part of the diagram as having
the same physical interpretation as the known field, and to enunciate our propositions in language based
upon such a conception, the unreality or even the impossibility of the states represented by the lines outside
of the known field cannot lead to any incorrect results in regard to paths in the known field.
8
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
The choice of the method of representation is of course to be determined by considera-
tions of simplicity and convenience, especially in regard to the drawing of the lines of equal
volume, pressure, temperature, energy and entropy, and the estimation of work and heat.
There is an obvious advantage in the use of diagrams of constant scale, in which the work
and heat are represented simply by areas. Such diagrams may of course be produced by an
infinity of different methods, as there is no limit to the ways of deforming a plane figure
without altering the magnitude of its elements. Among these methods, two are especially
important,—the ordinary method in which the volume and pressure are represented by rec-
tilinear co-ordinates, and that in which the entropy and temperature are so represented. A
diagram formed by the former method may be called, for the sake of distinction, a volume-
pressure diagram,—one formed by the latter, an entropy-temperature diagram. That the
latter as well as the former satisfies the condition that γ = 1 throughout the whole diagram,
may be seen by reference to page 5.
3 The Entropy-temperature Diagram compared with
that in ordinary use.
3.1 Considerations independent of the nature of the body in ques-
tion.
As the general equations (1), (2), (3) are not altered by interchanging v, −p and −W with
η, t and H respectively, it is evident that, so far as these equations are concerned, there
is nothing to choose between a volume-pressure and an entropy-temperature diagram. In
the former, the work is represented by an area bounded by the path which represents the
change of state of the body, two ordinates and the axis of abscissas. The same is true of
the heat received in the latter diagram. Again, in the former diagram, the heat received is
represented by an area bounded by the path and certain lines, the character of which depends
upon the nature of the body under consideration. Except in the case of an ideal body, the
properties of which are determined by assumption, these lines are more or less unknown in
a part of their course, and in any case the area will generally extend to an infinite distance.
Very much the same inconveniences attach themselves to the areas representing work in the
entropy-temperature diagram.
12
There is, however, a consideration of a general character,
12
In neither diagram do these circumstances create any serious difficulty in the estimation of areas rep-
resenting work or heat. It is always possible to divide these areas into two parts, of which one is of finite
dimensions, and the other can be calculated in the simplest manner. Thus in the entropy-temperature di-
agram the work done in a path AB (Figure 2) is represented by the area included by the path AB, the
isometric BC, the line of no pressure, and the isometric DA. The line of no pressure and the adjacent parts
of the isometrics in the case of an actual gas or vapor are more or less undetermined in the present state of
our knowledge, and are likely to remain so; for an ideal gas the line of no pressure coincides with the axis
of abscissas, and is an asymptote to the isometrics. But, be this as it may, it is not necessary to examine
the form of the remoter parts of the diagram. If we draw an isopiestic MN, cutting AD and BC, the area
MNCD, which represents the work done in MN, will be equal to p(v
00
− v
0
), where p denotes the pressure in
MN, and v
00
and v
0
denote the volumes at B and A respectively (eq. 5). Hence the work done in AB will
9
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
Figure 2
which shows an important advantage on the side of the entropy-temperature diagram. In
thermodynamic problems, heat received at one temperature is by no means the equivalent
of the same amount of heat received at another temperature. For example, a supply of a
million calories at 150
c
is a very different thing from a supply of a million calories at 50
c
.
But no such distinction exists in regard to work. This is a result of the general law, that heat
can only pass from a hotter to a colder body, while work can be transferred by mechanical
means from one fluid to any other, whatever may be the pressures. Hence, in thermodynamic
problems, it is generally necessary to distinguish between the quantities of heat received or
given out by the body at different temperatures, while as far as work is concerned, it is
generally sufficient to ascertain the total amount performed. If, then, several heat-areas and
one work-area enter into the problem, it is evidently more important that the former should
be simple in form, than that the latter should be so. Moreover, in the very common case of
a circuit, the work-area is bounded entirely by the path, and the form of the isometrics and
the line of no pressure are of no especial consequence.
Figure 3
It is worthy of notice that the simplest form of a perfect thermodynamic engine, so
often described in treatises on thermodynamics, is represented in the entropy-temperature
be represented by ABNM+p(v
00
− v
0
). In the volume-pressure diagram, the areas representing heat may be
divided by an isothermal, and treated in a manner entirely analogous.
Or we may make use of the principle that, for a path which begins and ends on the same isodynamic,
the work and heat are equal, as appears by integration of equation (1). Hence, in the entropy-temperature
diagram, to find the work of any path, we may extend it by an isometric (which will not alter its work), so
that it shall begin and end on the same isodynamic, and then take the heat (instead of the work) of the path
thus extended. This method was suggested by that employed by Cazin, Théorie élémentaire des machines
à air chaud, p. 11, and Zeuner, Mechanische Wärmetheorie, p. 80, in the reverse case, viz: to find the heat
of a path in the volume-pressure diagram.
10
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
diagram by a figure of extreme simplicity, viz: a rectangle of which the sides are parallel to
the co-ordinate axes. Thus in Figure 3, the circuit ABCD may represent the series of states
through which the fluid is made to pass in such an engine, the included area representing the
work done, while the area ABFE represents the heat received from the heater at the highest
temperature AE, and the area CDEF represents the heat transmitted to the cooler at the
lowest temperature DE.
There is another form of the perfect thermodynamic engine, viz: one with a perfect
regenerator as defined by Rankine, Phil. Trans. vol. 144, p. 140, the representation of
which becomes peculiarly simple in the entropy-temperature diagram. The circuit consists
of two equal straight lines AB and CD (fig. 4) parallel to the axis of abscissas, and two
precisely similar curves of any form BC and AD. The included area ABCD represents the
work done, and the areas ABba and CDdc represent respectively the heat received from the
heater and that transmitted to the cooler. The heat imparted by the fluid to the regenerator
Figure 4
in passing from B to C, and afterward restored to the fluid in its passage from D to A, is
represented by the areas BCcb and DAad.
It is often a matter of the first imnortance in the study of any thermodynamic engine,
to compare it with a perfect engine. Such a comparison will obviously be much facilitated
by the use of a method in which the perfect engine is represented by such simple forms.
The method in which the co-ordinates represent volume and pressure has a certain
advantage in the simple and elementary character of the notions upon which it is based, and
its analogy with Watt’s indicator has doubtless contributed to render it popular. On the
other hand, a method involving the notion of entropy, the very existence of which depends
upon the second law of thermodynamics, will doubtless seem to many far-fetched, and may
repel beginners as obscure and difficult of comprehension. This inconvenience is perhaps
more than counterbalanced by the advantages of a method which makes the second law of
thermodynamics so prominent, and gives it so clear and elementary an expression. The fact,
that the different states of a fluid can be represented by the positions of a point in a plane,
so that the ordinates shall represent the temperatures, and the heat received or given out by
the fluid shall be represented by the area bounded by the line representing the states through
which the body passes, the ordinates drawn through the extreme points of this line, and the
axis of abscissas,—this fact, clumsy as its expression in words may be, is one which presents
a clear image to the eye, and which the mind can readily grasp and retain. It is, however,
11
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
nothing more nor less than a geometrical expression of the second law of thermodynamics
in its application to fluids, in a form exceedingly convenient for use, and from which the
analytical expression of the same law can, if desired, be at once obtained. If, then, it is more
important for purposes of instruction and the like to familiarize the learner with the second
law, than to defer its statement as long as possible, the use of the entropy-temperature
diagram may serve a useful purpose in the popularizing of this science.
The foregoing considerations are in the main of a general character, and independent
of the nature of the substance to which the graphical method is applied. On this, however,
depend the forms of the isometrics, isopiestics and isodynamics in the entropy-temperature
diagram, and of the isentropics, isothermals and isodynamics in the volume-pressure diagram.
As the convenience of a method depends largely upon the ease with which these lines can
be drawn, and upon the peculiarities of the fluid which has its properties represented in the
diagram, it is desirable to compare the methods under consideration in some of their most
important applications. We will commence with the case of a perfect gas.
3.2 Case of a perfect gas.
A perfect or ideal gas may be defined as such a gas, that for any constant quantity of it the
product of the volume and the pressure varies as the temperature, and the energy varies as
the temperature, i.e.,
pv = at,
13
(A)
= ct. (B)
The significance of the constant a is sufficiently indicated by equation (A). The significance
of c may be rendered more evident by differentiating equation (B) and comparing the result
d = c dt
with the general equations (1) and (2), viz:
d = dH − dW, dW = p dv.
If dv = O, dW = O, and dH = c dt, i.e.,
dH
dt
!
v
= c,
14
(C)
i.e., c is the quantity of heat necessary to raise the temperature of the body one degree
under the condition of constant volume. It will be observed, that when different quantities
13
In this article, all equations which are designated by arabic numerals subsist for any body whatever
(subject to the condition of uniform pressure and temperature), and those which are designated by small
capitals subsist for any quantity of a perfect gas as defined above (subject of course to the same conditions).
14
A subscript letter after a differential co-efficient is used in this article to indicate the quantity which is
made constant in the differentiation.
12
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
of the same gas are considered, a and c both vary as the quantity, and c ÷a is constant; also,
that the value of c ÷ a for different gases varies as their specific heat determined for equal
volumes and for constant volume.
With the aid of equations (A) and (B) we may eliminate p and t from the general
equation (4), viz:
d = t dη − p dv,
which is then reduced to
d
=
1
c
dη −
a
c
dv
v
and by integration to log =
η
c
−
a
c
log v.
15
(D)
The constant of integration becomes 0, if we call the entropy 0 for the state of which the
volume and energy are both unity.
Any other equations which subsist between v, p, t, and η may be derived from the
three independent equations (A), (B) and (D). If we eliminate from (B) and (D), we have
η = a log v + c log t + c log c. (E)
Eliminating v from (A) and (E), we have
t = (a + c) log t − a log p + c log c + a log a. (F)
Eliminating t from (A) and (E), we have
η = (a + c) log v + c log p + c log c. (G)
If v is constant, equation (E) becomes
η = c log t + Const.,
i.e., the isometrics in the entropy-temperature diagram are logarithmic curves identical with
one another in form,—a change in the value of v having only the effect of moving the curve
parallel to the axis of η. If p is constant, equation (F) becomes
η = (a + c) log t + Const.,
so that the isopiestics in this diagram have similar properties. This identity in form dimin-
ishes greatly the labour of drawing any considerable number of these curves. For if a card or
thin board be cut in the form of one of them, it may be used as a pattern or ruler to draw
all of the same system.
15
If we use the letter e to denote the base of the Naperian system of logarithms, equation (D) may also
be written in the form
= e
η
c
v
−
a
c
.
This may be regarded as the fundamental thermodynamic equation of an ideal gas. See the last note on
page 2. It will be observed, that there would be no real loss of generality if we should choose, as the body to
which the letters refer, such a quantity of the gas that one of the constants a and c should be equal to unity.
13
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
The isodynamics are straight in this diagram (eq. B).
To find the form of the isothermals and isentropics in the volume-pressure diagram, we
may make t and η constant in equations (A) and (G) respectively, which will then reduce to
the well-known equations of these curves:—
pv = Const.,
and p
c
v
a+c
= Const.
The equation of the isodynamics is of course the same as that of the isothermals. None of
these systems of lines have that property of identity of form, which makes the systems of
isometrics and isopiestics so easy to draw in the entropy-temperature diagram.
3.3 Case of condensable vapors.
The case of bodies which pass from the liquid to the gaseous condition is next to be consid-
ered. It is usual to assume of such a body, that when sufficiently superheated it approaches
the condition of a perfect gas. If, then, in the entropy-temperature diagram of such body
we draw systems of isometrics, isopiestics and isodynamics, as if for a perfect gas, for proper
values of the constants a and c, these will be asymptotes to the true isometrics, etc., of the
vapor, and in many cases will not vary from them greatly in the part of the diagram which
represents vapor unmixed with liquid, except in the vicinity of the line of saturation. In the
volume-pressure diagram of the same body, the isothermals, isentropics and isodynamics,
drawn for a perfect gas for the same values of a and c, will have the same relations to the
true isothermals, etc.
In that part of any diagram which represents a mixture of vapor and liquid, the isopies-
tics and isothermals will be identical, as the pressure is determined by the temperature alone.
In both the diagrams which we are now comparing, they will be straight and parallel to the
axis of abscissas. The form of the isometrics and isodynamics in the entropy-temperature
diagram, or that of the isentropics and isodynamics in the volume-pressure diagram, will
depend upon the nature of the fluid, and probably cannot be expressed by any simple equa-
tions. The following property, however, renders it easy to construct equidifferent systems of
these lines, viz: any such system will divide any isothermal (isopiestic) into equal segments.
It remains to consider that part of the diagram which represents the body when entirely
in the condition of liquid. The fundamental characteristic of this condition of matter is
that the volume is very nearly constant, so that variations of volume are generally entirely
inappreciable when represented graphically on the same scale on which the volume of the
body in the state of vapor is represented, and both the variations of volume and the connected
variations of the connected quantities may be, and generally are, neglected by the side of the
variations of the same quantities which occur when the body passes to the state of vapor.
Let us make, then, the usual assumption that v is constant, and see how the general
14
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
equations (1), (2), (3) and (4) are thereby affected. We have first,
dv = 0,
then dW = 0,
and d = t dη.
If we add dH = t dη,
these four equations will evidently be equivalent to the three independent equations (1), (2)
and (3), combined with the assumption which we have just made. For a liquid, then, ,
instead of being a function of two quantities v and η, is a function of η alone,—t is also
a function of η alone, being equal to the differential co-efficient of the function ; that is,
the value of one of the three quantities t, and η, is sufficient to determine the other two.
The value of v, moreover, is fixed without reference to the values of tt, and η (so long as
these do not pass the limits of values possible for liquidity); while p does not enter into the
equations, i.e., p may have any value (within certain limits) without affecting the values of t,
and η or v. If the body change its state, continuing always liquid, the value of W for such
a change is 0, and that of H is determined by the values of any one of the three quantities
t, and η. It is, therefore, the relations between t, and η and H, for which a graphical
expression is to be sought; a method, therefore, in which the co-ordinates of the diagram
are made equal to the volume and pressure, is totally inapplicable to this particular case; v
and p are indeed the only two of the five functions of the state of the body, v, p, t, and η
which have no relations either to each other, or to the other three, or to the quantities W
and H, to be expressed.
16
The values of v and p do not really determine the state of an
incompressible fluid,—the values of t, and η are still left undetermined, so that through
every point in the volume-pressure diagram which represents the liquid there must pass (in
general) an infinite number of isothermals, isodynamics and isentropics. The character of
this part of the diagram is as follows:—the states of liquidity are represented by the points
of a line parallel to the axis of pressures, and the isothermals, isodynamics and isentropics,
which cross the field of partial vaporization and meet this line, turn upward and follow its
course.
17
In the entropy-temperature diagram the relations of t, and η are distinctly visible.
The line of liquidity is a curve AB (fig. 5) determined by the relation between t and η. This
curve is also an isometric. Every point of it has a definite volume, temperature, entropy and
energy. The latter is indicated by the isodynamics E
1
E
1
, E
2
E
2
, etc., which cross the region
of partial vaporization and terminate in the line of liquidity. (They do not in this diagram
turn and follow the line.) If the body pass from one state to another, remaining liquid, as
from M to N in the figure, the heat received is represented as usual by the area MNnm. That
the work done is nothing, is indicated by the fact that the line AB is an isometric. Only the
16
That is, v and p have no such relations to the other quantities, as are expressible by equations; p,
however, cannot be less than a certain function of t.
17
All these difficulties are of course removed when the differences of volume of the liquid at different
temperatures are rendered appreciable on the volume-pressure diagram. This can be done in various ways,—
among others, by choosing as the body to which v, etc., refer, a sufficiently large quantity of the fluid. But,
however we do it, we must evidently give up the possibility of representing the body in the state of vapor in
the same diagram without making its dimensions enormous.
15
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
Figure 5
isopiestics in this diagram are superposed in the line of fluidity, turning downward where
they meet this line and following its course, so that for any point in this line the pressure
is undetermined. This is, however, no inconvenience in the diagram, as it simply expresses
the fact of the case, that when all the quantities v, t, and η, are fixed, the pressure is still
undetermined.
4 Diagrams in which the Isometrics, Isopiestics, Isother-
mals, Isodynamics and Isentropics of a Perfect Gas
are all Straight Lines.
There are many cases in which it is of more importance that it should be easy to draw the
lines of equal volume, pressure, temperature, energy and entropy, than that work and heat
should be represented in the simplest manner. In such cases it may be expedient to give up
the condition that the scale (γ) of work and heat shall be constant, when by that means it
is possible to gain greater simplicity in the form of the lines just mentioned.
In the case of a perfect gas, the three relations between the quantities v, p, t, and
η are given on pages 12, 13, equations (A), (B) and (D). These equations may be easily
transformed into the three
log p + log v − log t = log a, (H)
log − log t = log c, (I)
η − c log − a log v = O; (J)
so that the three relations between the quantities log v, log p, log t, log and η are expressed
by linear equations, and it will be possible to make the five systems of lines all rectilinear in
the same diagram, the distances of the isometrics being proportional to the differences of the
logarithms of the volumes, the distances of the isopiestics being proportional to the differ-
ences of the logarithms of the pressures, and so with the isothermals and the isodynamics,—
16
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
the distances of the isentropics, however, being proportional to the differences of entropy
simply.
The scale of work and heat in such a diagram will vary inversely as the temperature.
For if we imagine systems of isentropics and isothermals drawn throughout the diagram
for equal small differences of entropy and temperature, the isentropics will be equidistant,
but the distances of the isothermals will vary inversely as the temperature, and the small
quadrilaterals into which the diagram is divided will vary in the same ratio: ∴ γ 1 ÷ t. (See
p. 5.)
So far, however, the form of the diagram has not been completely defined. This may be
done in various ways: e.g., if x and y be the rectangular co-ordinates, we may make
(
x = log v,
y = log p;
or
(
x = η,
y = log t;
or
(
x = log v,
y = η;
etc.
Or we may set the condition that the logarithms of volume, of pressure and of temperature,
shall be represented in the diagram on the same scale. (The logarithms of energy are nec-
essarily represented on the same scale as those of temperature.) This will require that the
isometrics, isopiestics and isothermals cut one another at angles of 60
◦
.
The general character of all these diagrams, which may be derived from one another by
projection by parallel lines, may be illustrated by the case in which x = log v, and y = log p.
Figure 6
Through any point A (fig 6)of such a diagram let there be drawn the isometric vv’, the
isopiestic pp’, the isothermal tt’ and the isentropic ηη
0
. The lines pp’ and vv’ are of course
parallel to the axes. Also by equation (H)
tan tAp =
dx
dy
!
t
=
d log p
d log v
!
t
= −1,
and by (G) tan ηAp =
dx
dy
!
η
=
d log p
d log v
!
η
= −
c + a
c
.
Therefore, if we draw another isometric, cutting ηη
0
, tt’, and pp’ in B, C and D,
BD
CD
=
c + a
c
,
BC
CD
=
a
c
, f racCDBC =
c
a
.
17
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
Hence, in the diagrams of different gases, CD÷BC will be proportional to the specific heat
determined for equal volumes and for constant volume.
As the specific heat, thus determined, has probably the same value for most simple
gases, the isentropics will have the same inclination in diagrams of this kind for most simple
gases. This inclination may easily be found by a method which is independent of any units
of measurement, for
BD : CD ::
d log p
d log v
!
η
:
d log p
d log v
!
t
::
dp
dv
!
η
:
dp
dv
!
t
,
i.e., BD÷CD is equal to the quotient of the co-efficient of elasticity under the condition of no
transmission of heat, divided by the coefficient of elasticity at constant temperature. This
quotient for a simple gas is generally given as 1.408 or 1.421. As
CA ÷ CD =
√
2 = 1.414,
BD is very nearly equal to CA (for simple gases), which relation it may be convenient to use
in the construction of the diagram.
In regard to compound gases the rule seems to be, that the specific heat (determined
for equal volumes and for constant volume) is to the specific heat of a simple gas inversely
as the volume of the compound is to the volume of its constituents (in the condition of gas);
that is, the value of BC÷CD for a compound gas is to the value of BC÷CD for a simple gas,
as the volume of the compound is to the volume of its constituents. Therefore, if we compare
the diagrams (formed by this method) for a simple and a compound gas, the distance DA
and therefore CD being the same in each, BC in the diagram of the compound gas will be
to BC in the diagram of the simple gas as the volume of the compound is to the volume of
its constituents.
Although the inclination of the isentropics is independent of the quantity of gas under
consideration, the rate of increase of η will vary with this quantity. In regard to the rate of
increase of t, it is evident that if the whole diagram be divided into squares by isopiestics
and isometrics drawn at equal distances, and isothermals be drawn as diagonals to these
squares, the volumes of the isometrics, the pressures of the isopiestics and the temperatures
of the isothermals will each form a geometrical series, and in all these series the ratio of two
contiguous terms will be the same.
The properties of the diagrams obtained by the other methods mentioned on page 17 do
not differ essentially from those just described. For example, in any such diagram, if through
any point we draw an isentropic, an isothermal and an isopiestic, which cut any isometric
not passing through the same point, the ratio of the segments of the isometric will have the
value which has been found for BC:CD.
In treating the case of vapors also, it may be convenient to use diagrams in which
x = log v and y = log p, or in which x = η and y = log t; but the diagrams formed by these
methods will evidently be radically different from one another. It is to be observed that each
of these methods is what may be called a method of definite scale for work and heat; that
18
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
is, the value of γ in any part of the diagram is independent of the properties of the fluid
considered. In the first method γ =
1
e
x+y
in the second γ =
1
e
y
. In this respect these methods
have an advantage over many others. For example, if we should make x = log v, y = η, the
value of γ in any part of the diagram would depend upon the properties of the fluid, and
would probably not vary in any case, except that of a perfect gas, according to any simple
law.
The conveniences of the entropy-temperature method will be found to belong in nearly
the same degree to the method in which the co-ordinates are equal to the entropy and the
logarithm of the temperature. No serious difficulty attaches to the estimation of heat and
work in a diagram formed on the latter method on account of the variation of the scale on
which they are represented, as this variation follows so simple a law. It may often be of use
to remember that such a diagram may be reduced to an entropy-temperature diagram by a
vertical compression or extension, such that the distances of the isothermals shall be made
proportional to their differences of temperature. Thus if we wish to estimate the work or heat
Figure 7
of the circuit ABCD (fig. 7), we may draw a number of equidistant ordinates (isentropics)
as if to estimate the included area, and for each of the ordinates take the differences of
temperature of the points where it cuts the circuit; these differences of temperature will
be equal to the lengths of the segments made by the corresponding circuit in the entropy-
temperature diagram upon a corresponding system of equidistant ordinates, and may be
used to calculate the area of the circuit in the entropy-temperature diagram, i.e., to find the
work or heat required. We may find the work of any path by applying the same process
to the circuit formed by the path, the isometric of the final state, the line of no pressure
(or any isopiestic; see note on page 9), and the isometric of the initial state. And we may
find the heat of any path by applying the same process to a circuit formed by the path, the
ordinates of the extreme points and the line of absolute cold. That this line is at an infinite
distance occasions no difficulty. The lengths of the ordinates in the entropy-temperature
diagram which we desire are given by the temperature of points in the path determined (in
either diagram) by equidistant ordinates.
The properties of the part of the entropy-temperature diagram representing a mixture
of vapor and liquid, which are given on page 14, will evidently not be altered if the ordinates
19
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
are made proportional to the logarithms of the temperatures instead of the temperatures
simply.
The representation of specific heat in the diagram under discussion is peculiarly simple.
The specific heat of any substance at constant volume or under constant pressure may be
defined as the value of
dH
dt
!
v
or
dH
dt
!
p
, i.e.,
dη
d log t
!
v
or
dη
d log t
!
p
,
for a certain quantity of the substance. Therefore, if we draw a diagram, in which x = η
and y = log t, for that quantity of the substance which is used for the determination of the
specific heat, the tangents of the angles made by the isometrics and the isopiestics with the
ordinates in the diagram will be equal to the specific heat of the substance determined for
constant volume and for constant pressure respectively. Sometimes, instead of the condition
of constant volume or constant pressure, some other condition is used in the determination
of specific heat. In all cases, the condition will be represented by a line in the diagram, and
the tangent of the angle made by this line with an ordinate will be equal to the specific heat
as thus defined. If the diagram be drawn for any other quantity of the substance, the specific
heat for constant volume or constant pressure, or for any other condition, will be equal to
the tangent of the proper angle in the diagram, multiplied by the ratio of the quantity of the
substance for which the specific heat is determined to the quantity for which the diagram is
drawn.
18
5 The Volume-entropy Diagram.
The method of representation, in which the co-ordinates of the point in the diagram are
made equal to the volume and entropy of the body, presents certain characteristics which
entitle it to a somewhat detailed consideration, and for some purposes give it substantial
advantages over any other method. We might anticipate some of these advantages from the
simple and symmetrical form of the general equations of thermodynamics, when volume and
entropy are chosen as independent variables, viz :—
19
p = −
d
dv
, (11)
t =
d
dη
, (12)
dW = p dv,
dH = t dη.
18
From this general property of the diagram, its character in the case of a perfect gas might be immediately
deduced.
19
See page 2, equations (2), (3) and (4).
In general, in this article, where differential coefficients are used, the quantity which is constant in the
differentiation is indicated by a subscript letter. In this discussion of the volume-entropy diagram, however,
v and η are uniformly regarded as the independent variables, and the subscript letter is omitted.
20
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
Eliminating p and t we have also
dW = −
d
dv
dv, (13)
dH =
d
dη
dη. (14)
The geometrical relations corresponding to these equations are in the volume-entropy dia-
gram extremely simple. To fix our ideas, let the axes of volume and entropy be horizontal
and vertical respectively, volume increasing toward the right and entropy upward. Then the
pressure taken negatively will equal the ratio of the difference of energy to the difference of
volume of two adjacent points in the same horizontal line, and the temperature will equal
the ratio of the difference of energy to the difference of entropy of two adjacent points in the
same vertical line. Or, if a series of isodynamics be drawn for equal infinitesimal differences
of energy, any series of horizontal lines will be divided into segments inversely proportional
to the pressure, and any series of vertical lines into segments inversely proportional to the
temperature. We see by equations (13) and (14), that for a motion parallel to the axis of
volume, the heat received is 0, and the work done is equal to the decrease of the energy,
while for a motion parallel to the axis of entropy, the work done. is 0, and the heat received
is equal to the increase of the energy. These two propositions are true either for elementary
paths or for those of finite length. In general, the work for any element of a path is equal to
the product of the pressure in that part of the diagram into the horizontal projection of the
element of the path, and the heat received is equal to the product of the temperature into
the vertical projection of the element of the path.
If we wish to estimate the value of the integrals
R
p dv and
R
t dη, which represent the
work and heat of any path, by means of measurements upon the diagram, or if we wish to
appreciate readily by the eye the approximate value of these expressions, or if we merely wish
to illustrate their meaning by means of the diagram; for any of these purposes the diagram
which we are now considering will have the advantage that it represents the differentials dv
and dη more simply and clearly than any other.
But we may also estimate the work and heat of any path by means of an integration
extending over the elements of an area, viz: by the formulae of page 7,
W
C
= H
C
=
C
X
1
γ
δA,
W
S
=
[S,v
00
,p
0
,v
0
]
X
1
γ
δA
H
S
=
[S,η
00
,t
0
,η
0
]
X
1
γ
δA
In regard to the limits of integration in these formulae, we see that for the work of any path
which is not a circuit, the bounding line is composed of the path, the line of no pressure and
two vertical lines, and for the heat of the path, the bounding line is composed of the path,
the line of absolute cold and two horizontal lines.
21
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
As the sign of γ, as well as that of A, will be indeterminate until we decide in which
direction an area must be circumscribed in order to be considered positive, we will call an
area positive which is circumscribed in the direction in which the hands of a watch move.
This choice, with the positions of the axes of volume and entropy which we have supposed,
will make the value of γ in most cases positive, as we shall see hereafter.
The value of γ, in a diagram drawn according to this method, will depend upon the
properties of the body for which the diagram is drawn. In this respect, this method differs
from all the others which have been discussed in detail in this article. It is easy to find an
expression for γ depending simply upon the variations of the energy, by comparing the area
and the work or heat of an infinitely small circuit in the form of a rectangle having its sides
parallel to the two axes.
Figure 8
Let N
1
N
2
N
3
N
4
(fig. 8) be such a circuit, and let it be described in the order of the
numerals, so that the area is positive. Also let
1
,
2
,
3
,
4
represent the energy at the four
corners. The work done in the four sides in order commencing at N
1
, will be
1
−
2
, 0,
3
−
4
, 0.
The total work, therefore, for the rectangular circuit is
1
−
2
+
3
−
4
.
Now as the rectangle is infinitely small, if we call its sides dv and dη, the above expression
will be equivalent to
−
d
2
dv dη
dv dη.
Dividing by the area dv dη, and writing γ
v,η
for the scale of work and heat in a diagram of
this kind, we have
1
γ
v,η
= −
d
2
dv dη
=
dp
dη
= −
dt
dv
.15 (15)
The two last expressions for the value of 1 ÷ γ
v,η
, indicate that the value of γ
v,η
in
different parts of the diagram will be indicated proportionally by the segments into which
vertical lines are divided by a system of equidifferent isopiestics, and also by the segments
into which horizontal lines are divided by a system of equidifferent isothermals. These results
might also be derived directly from the propositions on page 5.
As, in almost all cases, the pressure of a body is increased when it receives heat without
change of volume,
dp
dη
is in general positive, and the same will be true of γ
v,η
under the
22
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
assumptions which we have made in regard to the directions of the axes (page 21) and the
definition of a positive area (page 22).
In the estimation of work and heat it may often be of use to consider the deformation
necessary to reduce the diagram to one of constant scale for work and heat. Now if the
diagram be so deformed that each point remains in the same vertical line, but moves in this
line so that all isopiestics become straight and horizontal lines at distances proportional to
their differences of pressure, it will evidently become a volume-pressure diagram. Again,
if the diagram be so deformed that each point remains in the same horizontal line, but
moves in it so that isothermals become straight and vertical lines at distances proportional
to their differences of temperature, it will become an entropy-temperature diagram. These
considerations will enable us to compute numerically the work or heat of any path which is
given in a volume-entropy diagram, when the pressure and temperature are known for all
points of the path, in a manner analogous to that explained on page 19.
The ratio of any element of area in the volume-pressure or the entropy-temperature
diagram, or in any other in which the scale of work and heat is unity, to the corresponding
element in the volume-entropy diagram is represented by
1
γv,η
or −
d
2
dv dη
. The cases in which
this ratio is 0, or changes its sign, demand especial attention, as in such cases the diagrams
of constant scale fail to give a satisfactory representation of the properties of the body, while
no difficulty or inconvenience arises in the use of the volume-entropy diagram.
As −
d
2
dv dη
=
dp
dη
, its value is evidently zero in that part of the diagram which represents
the body when in part solid, in part liquid, and in part vapor. The properties of such a
mixture are very simply and clearly exhibited in the volume-entropy diagram.
Figure 9
Let the temperature and the pressure of the mixture, which are independent of the
proportions of vapor, solid and liquid, be denoted by t
0
and p
0
. Also let V, L and S (fig.
9) be points of the diagram which indicate the volume and entropy of the body in three
perfectly defined states, viz: that of a vapor of temperature t
0
and pressure p
0
, that of a
liquid of the same temperature and pressure, and that of a solid of the same temperature
and pressure. And let v
V
0
, η
V
0
, v
L
, η
L
, v
S
, η
S
denote the volume and entropy of these states.
The position of the point which represents the body, when part is vapor, part liquid, and
23
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
part solid, these parts being as µ, ν, and1 − µ − ν, is determined by the equations
v = µv
V
+ νv
L
+ (1 − µ − ν)v
S
,
η = µη
V
+ νη
L
+ (1 − µ − ν)η
S
,
where v and η are the volume and entropy of the mixture. The truth of the first equation is
evident. The second may be written
η − η
S
= µ(η
V
− η
S
) + ν(η
L
− η
S
),
or multiplying by t
0
,
t
0
(η − η
S
) = µt
0
(η
V
− η
S
) + νt
0
(η
L
− η
S
).
The first member of this equation denotes the heat necessary to bring the body from the
state S to the state of the mixture in question under the constant temperature t
0
, while the
terms of the second member denote separately the heat necessary to vaporize the part µ,
and to liquefy the part v of the body.
The values of v and η are such as would give the center of gravity of masses µ, ν and
1 −µ −ν placed at the points V, L and S.
20
Hence the part of the diagram which represents
a mixture of vapor, liquid and solid, is the triangle VLS. The pressure and temperature
are constant for this triangle, i.e., an isopiestic and also an isothermal here expand to cover
a space. The isodynamics are straight and equidistant for equal differences of energy. For
d
dp
= −p
0
and
d
dη
= t
0
, both of which are constant throughout the triangle.
This case can be but very imperfectly represented in the volume-pressure, or in the
entropy-temperature diagram. For all points in the same vertical line in the triangle VLS
will, in the volume-pressure diagram, be represented by a single point, as having the same
volume and pressure. And all the points in the same horizontal line will be represented
in the entropy-temperature diagram by a single point, as having the same entropy and
temperature. In either diagram, the whole triangle reduces to a straight line. It must reduce
to a line in any diagram whatever of constant scale, as its area must become 0 in such a
diagram. This must be regarded as a defect in these diagrams, as essentially different states
are represented by the same point. In consequence, any circuit within the triangle VLS
will be represented in any diagram of constant scale by two paths of opposite directions
superposed, the appearance being as if a body should change its state and then return to
its original state by inverse processes, so as to repass through the same series of states. It
is true that the circuit in question is like this combination of processes in one important
particular, viz: that W = H = 0, i.e., there is no transformation of heat into work. But this
very fact, that a circuit without transformation of heat into work is possible, is worthy of
distinct representation.
20
These points will not be in the same straight line unless
t
0
(η
V
− η
S
) : t
0
(η
L
− η
S
) :: v
V
− v
S
: v
L
− v
S
,
a condition very unlikely to be fulfilled by any substance. The first and second terms of this proportion
denote the heat of vaporization (from the solid state) and that of liquefaction.
24
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
A body may have such properties that in one part of the volumeentropy diagram
1
γ
v,η
,
i.e.,
dp
dη
is positive and in another negative. These parts of the diagram may be separated
by a line, in which
dp
dη
= 0,or by one in which
dp
dη
changes abruptly from a positive to a
negative value.
21
(In part, also, they may be separated by an area in which
dp
dη
= 0.) In the
representation of such cases in any diagram of constant scale, we meet with a difficulty of
the following nature.
Figure 10
Let us suppose that on the right of the line LL (fig. 10) in a volume-entropy diagram,
is positive, and on the left negative. Then, if we draw any circuit ABCD on the right side of
LL, the direction being that of the hands of a watch, the work and heat of the circuit will
be positive. But if we draw any circuit EFGH in the same direction on the other side of the
line LL, the work and heat will be negative. For
W = H =
X
1
γ
v,η
δA =
X
dp
dη
δA.
and the direction of the circuits makes the areas positive in both cases. Now if we should
change this diagram into any diagram of constant scale, the areas of the circuits, as rep-
resenting proportionally the work done in each case, must necessarily have opposite signs,
i.e., the direction of the circuits must be opposite. We will suppose that the work done is
positive in the diagram of constant scale, when the direction of the circuit is that of the
hands of a watch. Then, in that diagram, the circuit ABCD would have that direction, and
the circuit EFGH the contrary direction, as in Figure 11. Now if we imagine an indefinite
number of circuits on each side of LL in the volume-entropy diagram, it will be evident that
to transform such a diagram into one of constant scale, so as to change the direction of all
the circuits on one side of LL, and of none on the other the diagram must be folded over
along that line; so that the points on one side of LL in a diagram of constant scale do not
represent any states of the body, while on the other side of this line, each point, for a certain
21
The line which represents the various states of water at its maximum density for various constant
pressures is an example of the first case. A substance which as a liquid has no proper maximum density for
constant pressure, but which expands in solidifying, affords an example of the second case.
25
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
Figure 11
distance at least, represents two different states of the body, which in the volume-entropy
diagram are represented by points on opposite sides of the line LL. We have thus in a part
of the field two diagrams superposed, which must be carefully distinguished. If this be done,
as by the help of different colors, or of continuous and dotted lines, or otherwise, and it is
remembered that there is no continuity between these superposed diagrams, except along
the bounding line LL, all the general theorems which have been developed in this article
can be readily applied to the diagram. But to the eye or to the imagination, the figure will
necessarily be much more confusing than a volume-entropy diagram.
If
dp
dη
= O for the line LL, there will be another inconvenience in the use of any diagram
of constant scale, viz: in the vicinity of the line LL,
dp
dη
, i.e., 1 ÷ γ
v,η
, will have a very
small value, so that areas will be very greatly reduced in the diagram of constant scale, as
compared with the corresponding areas in the volume-entropy diagram. Therefore, in the
former diagram, either the isometrics, or the isentropics, or both, will be crowded together
in the vicinity of the line LL, so that this part of the diagram will be necessarily indistinct.
Figure 12
It may occur, however, in the volume-entropy diagram, that the same point must rep-
resent two different states of the body. This occurs in the case of liquids which can be
vaporized. Let MM (fig. 12) be the line representing the states of the liquid bordering
upon vaporization. This line will be near to the axis of entropy, and nearly parallel to it.
26
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
If the body is in a state represented by a point of the line MM, and is compressed without
addition or subtraction of heat, it will remain of course liquid. Hence, the points of the
space immediately on the left of MM represent simple liquid. On the other hand, the body
being in the original state, if its volume should be increased without addition or subtraction
of heat, and if the conditions necessary for vaporization are present (conditions relative to
the body enclosing the liquid in question, etc.), the liquid will become partially vaporized,
but if these conditions are not present, it will continue liquid. Hence, every point on the
right of MM and sufficiently near to it represents two different states of the body, in one of
which it is partially vaporized, and in the other it is entirely liquid. If we take the points
as representing the mixture of vapor and liquid, they form one diagram, and if we take
them as representing simple liquid, they form a totally different diagram superposed on the
first. There is evidently no continuity between these diagrams except at the line MM; we
may regard them as upon separate sheets united only along MM. For the body cannot pass
from the state of partial vaporization to the state of liquid except at this line. The reverse
process is indeed possible; the body can pass from the state of superheated liquid to that
of partial vaporization, if the conditions of vaporization alluded to above are supplied, or
if the increase of volume is carried beyond a certain limit, but not by gradual changes or
reversible processes. After such a change, the point representing the state of the body will
be found in a different position from that which it occupied before, but the change of state
cannot be properly represented by any path, as during the change the body does not satisfy
that condition of uniform temperature and pressure which has been assumed throughout
this article, and which is necessary for the graphical methods under discussion. (See note on
page 1.)
Of the two superposed diagrams, that which represents simple liquid is a continuation
of the diagram on the left of MM. The isopiestics, isothermals and isodynamics pass from
one to the other without abrupt change of direction or curvature. But that which repre-
sents a mixture of vapor and liquid will be different in its character, and its isopiestics and
isothermals will make angles in general with the corresponding lines in the diagram of simple
liquid. The isodynamics of the diagram of the mixture, and those of the diagram of simple
liquid, will differ in general in curvature at the line MM, but not in direction, for
d
dv
= −p
and
d
dη
= t.
The case is essentially the same with some substances, as water, for example, about the
line which separates the simple liquid from a mixture of liquid and solid.
In these cases the inconvenience of having one diagram superposed upon another cannot
be obviated by any change of the principle on which the diagram is based. For no distortion
can bring the three sheets, which are united along the line MM (one on the left and two
on the right), into a single plane surface without superposition. Such cases, therefore, are
radically distinguished from those in which the superposition is caused by an unsuitable
method of representation.
To find the character of a volume-entropy diagram of a perfect gas, we may make
constant in equation (D) on page 13, which will give for the equation of an isodynamic and
isothermal
η = a log v + Const.,
27
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
and we may make p constant in equation (G), which will give for the equation of an isopiestic
η = (a + c) log v + Const.,
It will be observed that all the isodynamics and isothermals can be drawn by a single pattern
and so also with the isopiestics.
The case will be nearly the same with vapors in a part of the diagram. In that part
of, the diagram which represents a mixture of liquid and vapor, the isothermals, which of
course are identical with the isopiestics, are straight lines. For when a body is vaporized
under constant pressure and temperature, the quantities of heat received are proportional
to the increments of volume; therefore, the increments of entropy are proportional to the
increments of volume. As
d
dv
= −p and
d
dη
= p, any isothermal is cut at the same angle by
all the isodynamics, and is divided into equal segments by equidifferent isodynamics. The
latter property is useful in drawing systems of equidifferent isodynamics.
6 Arrangement of the Isometric, Isopiestic, Isothermal
and Isentropic about a Point.
The arrangement of the isometric, the isopiestic, the isothermal and the isentropic drawn
through any same point, in respect to the order in which they succeed one another around
that point, and in respect to the sides of these lines toward which the volume, pressure,
temperature and entropy increase, is not altered by any deformation of the surface on which
the diagram is drawn, and is therefore independent of the method by which the diagram is
formed.
22
This arrangement is determined by certain of the most characteristic thermody-
namic properties of the body in the state in question, and serves in turn to indicate these
properties. It is determined, namely, by the value of
dp
dη
v
as positive, negative, or zero, i.e.,
by the effect of heat as increasing or diminishing the pressure when the volume is maintained
constant, and by the nature of the internal thermodynamic equilibrium of the body as stable
or neutral,—an unstable equilibrium, except as a matter of speculation, is of course out of
the question.
Let us first examine the case in which
dp
dη
v
is positive and the equilibrium is stable. As
dp
dη
v
does not vanish at the point in question, there is a definite isopiestic passing through
that point, on one side of which the pressures are greater, and on the other less, than on
the line itself. As
dt
dv
η
= −
dp
dη
v
, the case is the same with the isothermal. It will be
convenient to distinguish the sides of the isometric, isopiestic, etc., on which the volume,
pressure, etc., increase, as the positive sides of these lines. The condition of stability requires
that, when the pressure is constant, the temperature shall increase with the heat received,—
22
It is here assumed that, in the vicinity of the point in question, each point in the diagram represents
only one state of the body. The propositions developed in the following pages cannot be applied to points
of the line where two superposed diagrams are united (see pages 25-28) without certain modifications.
28
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
therefore with the entropy. This may be written [dt : dη]
p
> O.
23
It also requires that, when
there is no transmission of heat, the pressure should increase as the volume diminishes, i.e.,
that [dp : dv]
η
> O. Through the point in question, A (fig. 13), let there be drawn the
Figure 13
isometric vv’ and the isentropic ηη
0
, and let the positive sides of these lines be indicated as
in the figure. The conditions
dp
dη
v
> 0 and [dp : dv]
η
< 0 require that the pressure at v
and at η shall be greater than at A, and hence, that the isopiestic shall fall as pp’ in the
figure, and have its positive side turned as indicated. Again, the conditions
dt
dv
η
< 0 and
[dt : dη]
p
> 0 require that the temperature at η and at p shall be greater than at A, and
hence, that the isothermal shall fall as tt’ and have its positive side turned as indicated. As
it is not necessary that
dt
dη
p
> 0, the lines pp’ and tt’ may be tangent to one another at A,
provided that they cross one another, so as to have the same order about the point A as is
represented in the figure; i.e., they may have a contact of the second (or any even) order.
24
But the condition that
dp
dη
v
> 0, and hence
dt
dv
η
< 0, does not allow pp’ to be tangent to
vv’, nor tt’ to ηη
0
.
If
dp
dη
v
be still positive, but the equilibrium be neutral, it will be possible for the body
to change its state without change either of temperature or of pressure; i.e., the isothermal
and isopiestic will be identical. The lines will fall as in Figure 13, except that the isothermal
and isopiestic will be superposed.
In like manner, if
dp
dη
v
< 0, it may be proved that the lines will fall as in Figure 14 for
stable equilibrium, and in the same way for neutral equilibrium, except that pp’ and tt’ will
23
As the notation
dt
dη
is used to denote the limit of the ratio of dt to dη, it would not be quite accurate
to say that the condition of stability requires that
dt
dη
p
> 0. This condition requires that the ratio of the
differences of temperature and entropy between the point in question and any other infinitely near to it and
upon the same isopiestic should be positive. It is not necessary that the limit of this ratio should be positive.
24
An example of this is doubtless to be found at the critical point of a fluid. See Dr. Andrews “On the
continuity of the gaseous and liquid states of matter.” Phil. Trans., vol. 159, p. 575.
If the isothermal and isopiestic have a simple tangency at A, on one side of that point they will have such
directions as will express an unstable equilibrium. A line drawn through all such points in the diagram will
form a boundary to the possible part of the diagram. It may be that the part of the diagram of a fluid,
which represents the superheated liquid state, is bounded on one side by such a line.
29
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
be superposed.
25
Figure 14
The case that
dp
dη
v
= 0 includes a considerable number of conceivable cases, which
would require to be distinguished. It will be sufficient to mention those most likely to occur.
In a field of stable equilibrium it may occur that P) along a line, on one side of which
dp
dη
v
> 0, and on the other side
dp
dη
v
< 0. At any point in such a line the isopiestics will
be tangent to the isometrics and the isothermals to the isentropics. (See, however, note on
page 29.)
In a field of neutral equilibrium representing a mixture of two different states of the
substance, where the isothermals and isopiestics are identical, a line may occur which has
the threefold character of an isometric, an isothermal and an isopiestic. For such a line
dp
dη
v
= 0. If
dp
dη
v
has opposite signs on opposite sides of this line, it will be an isothermal
of maximum or minimum temperature.
26
The case in which the body is partly solid, partly
liquid and partly vapor has already been sufficiently discussed. (See pages 23, 24.)
The arrangement of the isometric, isopiestic, etc., as given in Figure 13, will indicate
directly the sign of any differential co-efficient of the form
du
dw
z
, where u, w and z may
be any of the quantities v, p, t, η (and , if the isodynamic be added in the figure). The
value of such a differential co-efficient will be indicated, when the rates of increase of v,
p, etc., are indicated, as by isometrics, etc., drawn both for the values of v, etc., at the
point A, and for values differing from these by a small quantity. For example, the value
of
dp
dη
v
will be indicated by the ratio of the segments intercepted upon an isentropic by a
pair of isometrics and a pair of isopiestics, of which the differences of volume and pressure
25
When it is said that the arrangement of the lines in the diagram must be like that in figure 13 or
in figure 14, it is not meant to exclude the case in which the figure (13 or 14) must be turned over, in
order to correspond with the diagram. In the case, however, of diagrams formed by any of the methods
mentioned in this article, if the directions of the axes be such as we have assumed, the agreement with
Figure 13 will be without inversion, and the agreement with Figure 14 will also be without inversion for
volume-entropy diagrams, but with inversion for volume-pressure or entropy-temperature diagrams, or those
in which x = log v and y = log p, or x = η and y = log t.
26
As some liquids expand and others contract in solidifying, it is possible that there are some which will
solidify either with expansion, or without change of volume, or with contraction, according to the pressure.
If any such there are, they afford examples of the case mentioned above.
30
Equilibrium of Heterogeneous Substances Last edit: January 27, 2016
have the same numerical value. The case in which W or H appears in the numerator or
denominator instead of a function of the state of the body, can be reduced to the preceding
by the substitution of p dv for dW , or that of t dη for dH.
In the foregoing discussion, the equations which express the fundamental principles
of thermodynamics in an analytical form have been assumed, and the aim has only been
to show how the same relations may be expressed geometrically. It would, however, be
easy, starting from the first and second laws of thermodynamics as usually enunciated, to
arrive at the same results without the aid of analytical formula,—to arrive, for example,
at the conception of energy, of entropy, of absolute temperature, in the construction of
the diagram without the analytical definitions of these quantities, and to obtain the various
properties of the diagram without the analytical expression of the thermodynamic properties
which they involve. Such a course would have been better fitted to show the independence
and sufficiency of a graphical method, but perhaps less suitable for an examination of the
comparative advantages or disadvantages of different graphical methods.
The possibility of treating the thermodynamics of fluids by such graphical methods as
have been described evidently arises from the fact that the state of the body considered, like
the position of a point in a plane, is capable of two and only two independent variations.
It is, perhaps, worthy of notice, that when the diagram is only used to demonstrate or
illustrate general theorems, it is not necessary, although it may be convenient, to assume
any particular method of forming the diagram; it is enough to suppose the different states
of the body to be represented continuously by points upon a sheet.
31

Discussion

Tap the paper where you want to comment