The colonization of space

By Gerard K. O'Neill, 1974

Annotated on Fermat's Library with 15 comments. Text and annotations as Markdown Original paper

Gerard Kitchen O’Neill (1927–1992) was a Princeton physicist whose ...
### Spaceflight in September 1974 Only about 73 people had ever ...
Konstantin Tsiolkovsky (1857–1935) was a nearly deaf, largely self-...
If you want to explore a 3d visualization of a O’Neill Cylinder go ...
**Why two?** The colony sits at L5, a stable point in the Moon's or...
**Why four miles?** O'Neill assumes the cylinder is held together b...
O’Neill was writing just two years after the last Apollo landing, a...
**Longerons.** The word comes from aircraft design, where a longero...
How size shapes the environment. Gravity doesn’t depend on size bec...
**Keeping it lit and temperate.** A habitat in space faces two link...
Depiction of the agricultural Cylinders ![](https://i.imgur.com/n...
**The Apollo seismic network** Apollo astronauts left seismometers ...
**The Prairie Network** A set of 16 automatic camera stations ac...
O’Neill works backward from demand. He assumes 100,000 residents ea...
**Shielding from radiation** In this paper O’Neill underestimat...
The colonization of space
Careful engineering and cost analysis shows we can build
pleasant, self-sufficient dwelling places in space within the
next two decades, solving many of Earth's problems.
Gerard K. O'Neill
New ideas are controversial when they
challenge orthodoxy, but orthodoxy
changes with time, often surprisingly
fast. It is orthodox, for example, to be-
lieve that Earth is the only practical ha-
bitat for Man, and that the human race
is close to its ultimate size limits. But I
believe we have now reached the point
where we can, if we so choose, build new
habitats far more comfortable, produc-
tive and attractive than is most of
Earth.
Although thoughts about migration
into space are as old as science fiction,
the technical basis for serious calcula-
tion did not exist until the late
1960's.
In addition, a mental
"hangup"—the
fixed idea of planets as colony
sites—
appears to have trapped nearly every-
one who has considered the problem,
including, curiously enough, almost all
science-fiction writers. In recent
months I learned that the space pioneer
Konstantin Tsiolkowsky, in his dreams
of the future, was one of the first to es-
cape that hangup.
By chance, and initially almost as a
joke,
I began some calculations on the
problem in 1969, at first as an exercise
for the most ambitious students in an
introductory physics course. As some-
times happens in the hard sciences,
what began as a joke had to be taken
more seriously when the numbers began
to come out right. There followed sev-
eral years of frustrating attempts to get
these studies published.
Friends advised that I take my ideas
"to the people" in the form of physics
Gerard K. O'Neill is professor of physics at
Princeton University.
lectures at universities. The positive
response (especially from students) en-
couraged me to dig harder for the an-
swers to questions about
.
meteoroid
damage, agricultural productivity, ma-
terials sources, economics and other
topics. The results of that study indi-
cate that
• we can colonize space, and do so
without robbing or harming anyone and
without polluting anything.
• if work is begun soon, nearly all our
industrial activity could be moved away
from Earth's fragile biosphere within
less than a century from now.
• the technical imperatives of this kind
of migration of people and industry into
space are likely to encourage self-suffi-
ciency, small-scale governmental units,
cultural diversity and a high degree of
independence.
• the ultimate size limit for the human
race on the newly available frontier is at
least 20 000 times its present value.
How can colonization take place? It
is possible even with existing technolo-
gy, if done in the most efficient ways.
New methods are needed, but none goes
beyond the range of present-day knowl-
edge.
The challenge is to bring the goal
of space colonization into economic fea-
sibility now, and the key is to treat the
region beyond Earth not as a void but
as a culture medium, rich in matter and
energy. To live normally, people need
energy, air, water, land and gravity. In
space, solar energy is dependable and
convenient to use; the Moon and aster-
oid belt can supply the needed materi-
als,
and rotational acceleration can sub-
for Earth's gravity.
Space exploration so far, like Antarc-
tic exploration before it, has consisted
of short-term scientific expeditions,
wholly dependent for survival on
supplies brought from home. If, in
contrast, we use the matter and energy
available in space to colonize and build,
we can achieve great productivity of
food and material goods. Then, in a
time short enough to be useful, the ex-
ponential growth of colonies can reach
the point at which the colonies can be of
great benefit to the entire human race.
To show that we are technically able
to begin such a development now, this
discussion will be limited to the tech-
nology of the
1970's,
assuming only
those structural materials that already
exist. Within a development that may
span 100 years, this assumption is un-
realistically conservative. We shall
look at the individual space communi-
ties—their
structure and appearance
and the activities possible for their in-
habitants, their relation to the space
around them, sources of food, travel be-
tween communities as well as to Earth,
the economics of the colonies and plans
for their growth. As is usual in physics,
it is valuable to consider limiting cases:
for this study, the limits are an eventual
full-size space community on a scale es-
tablished by the strength of materials,
and a first model, for which cost esti-
mates can reasonably be made. The
goals of the proposal will be clearer if
we first discuss the large community.
A cylindrical habitat
The geometry of each space commu-
nity is fairly closely defined if all of the
following conditions are required: nor-
mal gravity, normal day and night cycle,
3 2
PHYSICS TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
natural sunlight, an earthlike appear-
ance,
efficient use of solar power and of
materials. The most effective geometry
satisfying all of these conditions ap-
pears to be a pair of cylinders. The
economics of efficient use of materials
tends to limit their size to about four
miles in diameter, and perhaps about 16
miles in length. (See figure 1.) In
these cylinder pairs, the entire land
area is devoted to living space, parkland
and forest, with lakes, rivers, grass,
trees,
animals and birds, an environ-
ment like most attractive parts of
Earth; agriculture is carried on else-
where. The circumference is divided
into alternating strips of land area
("valleys") and window area ("solars").
The rotation period is two minutes, and
the cylinder axes are always pointed
toward the Sun.
Because the Moon is a rich source
both of titanium and of aluminum, it is
likely that these metals will be used ex-
tensively in the colonies. For conserva-
tism, though, the calculation of the cyl-
inder structure has been based on the
use of steel cables, to form "longerons"
(longitudinal members carrying the at-
mospheric forces on the end caps) and
circumferential bands (carrying the at-
mospheric force and the spin-induced
weights of the ground, of
the
longerons
and of themselves. For details of this
calculation and the assumptions it in-
cludes, see the box on page 34.) The
steel cables are bunched to form a
coarse mesh in the window areas. The
bands there subtend a visual angle of
2.3 X
10~
4
radians, about equal to the
diffraction limit for the sunlight-adapt-
ed human eye, and so are nearly invisi-
Natural
sunlight from planar mirrors
Illllil
Rotation
Earthbound
structures for scale
1000 2000
Meters
3000
Section of a space-community main cylinder (top). The circumference is divided into alternat-
ing strips of land area (valleys) and window area (solars). Although the space-community val-
leys offer new landscaping opportunities and architectural possibilities, it is reassuring to note
that certain Earth features can be recreated: the side view of a cylinder end cap (bottom) in-
cludes a mountain profile taken from an aerial photograph of a section of the Grand Teton range
in Wyoming. Figure 1
PHYSICS
TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
33
Table
1.
Possible Stages in the Development
of Space Communities
Model
1
2
3
4
Length
(km)
1
3.2
10
32
Radius
(m)
100
320
1000
3200
Period
(sec)
21
36
63
114
Population*
10 000
100-200 X 10
3
0.2-2 X 10
6
0.2-20 X 10
6
Earliest
estimated
date
1988
1996
2002
2008
* Population
figures a re
for double
unit;
higher figures are the approximate ecological limits, for
conventional agriculture.
Table 2. Masses of Materials Required for
Model 1 ( M et ric tons)
Aluminum (container, structures)
Glass (solars)
Water
Generator plant
Initial structures
Special fabricated hardware
Machines and tools
Soil,
rock and construction materials
Liquid hydrogen
2000 people and equipment
Dehydrated food
Totals
Total mass
required
20 000
10 000
50
000
l
1000
2
1000
1000
800
420 000
1
5400
200
600
Mass required
from Earth
1000
1000
1000
800
5400
200
600
>500
000 10 000
1
Includesreplenishable reserves
to be used to
initiate
construction of Model
2,
and so are higher
than the minima required for Model 1.
2
For 100 MW plant.
Steel structure
For the structure, steel cables are assumed to be formed into longerons (average thick-
ness
Ar
L
)
and circular bands (average thickness
lr
B
).
The value of
Ar
L
required is
Ar,.
=
Rp,,/2T
where R is the cylinder radius,
po
the atmospheric pressure and
7"the
tension. For land
density
p
L
and depth
x,_,
and bands of density
p
F
,
the total equivalent internal pressure
pj
is
To solve for
pj
we note that
Ar
h
=
p
T
R/T
so that
PT =
(p
t
,
+
gp,,x
L
+
gp
F
R/T)/a
-
For an average soil depth of 150 cm, with an average density of 1.5
gm
per cc,
Pn =
gP[X
L
=
1.2.3
X 10'
newtons/m
2
To arrive at a conservative value for T, we note that half a century ago, the working
stress for suspension-bridge cables was 70 000 to 80 000 pounds per square
inch.
1
At
that time, D. B. Steinman argued
1
for the use of stresses over 100 000 psi. If we use
1920's
steels, hardened to bring the yield point to 90% of the ultimate strength, and work
at 75% of the yield point, the working stress can be 152 000 psi. If we take
fas
150 000 psi and R as 3200 meters, the averaged surface mass density is 7.5 tons per
square meter.
In the window (solar) areas, the longerons can be 0.8-meter cables in stacks of four at
14-meter intervals. The bands can be in the same arrangement, but with a
1.5-meter
di-
ameter, and the mesh transparency will then be 84%. Considerably larger values of R
would result from the extensive use of titanium in the structure, together with a thinner
layer of earth.
ble.
The windows themselves are of
glass or plastic, subdivided into small
panels.
There is no sharp upper limit on the
size of a space-community cylinder;
with increasing size, though, a larger
fraction of the total mass is in the form
of supporting cables. The figure 3200
meters for radius R is somewhat arbi-
trary. Economoy would favor a smaller
size;
use of high-strength materials, or a
strong desire for an even more earthlike
environment, would favor a larger. In-
dependent of size, the apparent gravity
is earth-normal, and the air composi-
tion as well as the atmospheric pressure
are those of sea level on Earth. For R
equal to 3200 meters, the atmospheric
depth is that of an Earth location at
3300 meters above sea level, an altitude
where the sky is blue and the climate
habitable: At any radius r within the
cylinder we have
where
a
=
gpJ2Rp
0
=
X
10-
4
/meter)
The length of a day in each communi-
ty is controlled by opening and closing
the main mirrors that rotate with the
cylinders. The length of day then sets
the average temperature and seasonal
variation within the cylinder. Each
cylinder can be thought of as a heat
sink equivalent to 3 X 10
8
tons of water;
for complete heat exchange, the warm-
up rate in full daylight would be about
0.7 deg C per hour. As on Earth, the
true
warmup
rate is higher because the
ground more than a few centimeters
below the surface does not follow the
diurnal variation.
Bird and animal species that are en-
dangered on Earth by agricultural and
industrial chemical residues may find
havens for growth in the space colonies,
where insecticides are unnecessary, ag-
ricultural areas are physically separate
from living areas, and industry has un-
limited energy for recycling.
As we can see in figure 1, it is possible
to recreate certain Earth features: the
mountain profile is taken from an aerial
photograph of a section of the Grand
Teton range in Wyoming. The calcu-
lated cloud base heights as seen in the
figure are typical of summer weather on
Earth: For a dry adiabatic lapse rate of
3.1 deg per 300 meters and a dew-point
lapse rate of 0.56 deg per 300 meters,
50%
relative humidity and a tempera-
ture range between zero and 32°C, the
cloud base heights range between 1100
and 1400 meters.
Environmental control
The agricultural areas are separate
from the living areas, and each one has
the best climate for the particular crop
it is to grow. Gravity, atmosphere and
34
PHYSICS TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
insolation are earthlike in most agricul-
tural cylinders, but there is no attempt
there to simulate an earthlike appear-
ance.
Selected seeds in a sterile, isolat-
ed environment initiate growth, so that
no insecticides or pesticides are needed.
(The evolution time for infectious orga-
nisms is long, and resterilization of a
contaminated agricultural cylinder by
heating would not be difficult.) All
food can be fresh, because it is grown
only 20 miles from the point of use.
The agricultural cylinders can be evenly
distributed in seasonal phase, so that at
any given time several of them are at
the right month for harvesting any de-
sired crop.
Figure 2 shows side and end views of
a space community as a complete eco-
system. The main mirrors are made of
aluminum foil and are planar. Moving
these mirrors varies the angle at which
sunlight hits the valleys (controlling the
diurnal cycle), and the Sun appears mo-
tionless in the sky, as it does on Earth.
The solar power stations, which consist
of paraboloidal mirrors, boiler tubes
and conventional steam-turbine electric
generators, can provide the community
with sufficient power, easily up to ten
times the power per person now used
(10 kw) in highly industrialized re-
gions.
2
For such energy-rich conditions
(120 kw per person) the power needed
for a cylinder housing 100 000 people is
12
000 megawatts: The solar power in-
cident on a cylinder end cap is 36 000
megawatts, adequate if the thermal effi-
ciency is
33%.
Extra power plants near
the agricultural ring would be needed
for higher population density. Waste
heat is sent into space by infrared radi-
ators of low directionality.
The communities are protected from
cosmic rays by the depth of the atmo-
sphere and by the land and steel sup-
porting structure, the bands and longer-
ons being distributed where visual
transparency is unnecessary. Meteor-
oid damage should not be a serious dan-
ger. Most meteoroids are of cometary
rather than asteroidal origin and are
dust conglomerates, possibly bound by
frozen gases;
3
a typical meteoroid is
more like a snowball than like a rock.
Spacecraft sensors have collected abun-
dant and consistent data on meteoroids
in the range
10~
6
to 1 gram, and the
Apollo lunar seismic network is believed
to have 100% detection efficiency for
meteoroids
4
above 10 kg: Data from
these sources are consistent with a sin-
gle distribution law.
The Prairie Network sky-camera
data,
5
after substantial correction for
assumed luminous efficiency, agree with
data from the National Aeronautics and
Space Administration for
10-gm
mete-
oroids. The spacecraft and seismic
data indicate a mean interval of about
one-million years for a strike by a heavy
(one ton) meteoroid on a space commu-
nity of cross section 1000 square kilo-
meters. Even such a strike should pro-
duce only local damage if the structure
is well designed. For 100-gram meteor-
oids,
the mean interval for a strike is
about three years. From the combined
viewpoints of frequency and of momen-
tum carried, the size range from one to
ten grams may need the most care in
window design and repair methods.
For total breakage of one window panel,
Daniel Villani at Princeton has calcu-
lated a leakdown time of about 300
years.
Meteoroid-damage control is,
then, a matter of sensing and of regular
minor repair rather than of sudden
emergencies.
Axial rotation and transport
A key element in the design of the
space colony is the coupling of two cyl-
inders by a tension cable and a com-
pression tower to form a system that
has zero axial angular momentum and
is therefore able to maintain its axis
pointed toward the Sun without the use
of thrusters. The force and torque di-
agram for this arrangement is seen in
figure 3. To accelerate the cylinders up
to the required rotational speed, static
torque is transmitted through the com-
pression framework that joins the two
cylinders of a pair. For a spin-up time
of three years, a constant 560 000 horse-
power is needed; this is
3%
of the gener-
ator capacity of a cylinder. After spin-
up,
the same motors can provide main-
tenance power for frictional losses and
for attitude control about the spin axis.
Each cylinder's angular momentum is
1.5 X 10
18
kg
2
rad per sec; the torque
needed to precess this angular momen-
tum once each year is 3 X 10
11
newton
meters, corresponding to a constant
force of 1200 tons on a 26-km lever arm.
The phase difference of seasons be-
tween the two cylinders permits "sea-
sonal counterpoint," midsummer in one
cylinder during midwinter in the other.
Travel between the two requires no
power and only nine minutes of time.
They are only 90 km apart, and engine-
less vehicles can unlock from the outer
surface of one cylinder at a preset time,
move in free flight with the tangential
velocity (180 meters per sec or 400 miles
per hour) and lock on to the other cylin-
der at zero relative velocity.
Travel between communities can also
be carried out with simple engineless
vehicles, accelerated in a computed di-
rection by a stationary cable-pulling
electric motor and decelerated by an ar-
resting cable at the destination. The
"cable-car" vehicles for such free flight
need no fuel, no complex maintenance
nor a highly trained crew, and should be
inexpensive. Vehicle speeds permit
travel among a total population larger
than that of Earth within flight times of
seven hours. (I have here assumed
communities spaced at 200-km inter-
vals,
so that the maximum dimension of
a planar cluster housing 4 billion people
is 29 000 km. For a vehicle with
accel-
0 5 10
Main mirrors
Distant-travel'
launch track
Agricultural areas
Sunlight
Space-community Solar-power stations
main cylinder
Midline
between members of cylinder-pairs
Agricultural areas (37 of 72 shown)
Space community as a whole is seen in side (left) and end (right)
views.
For the end view, 37 of the 72 agricultural cylinders in a ring
are shown; the ring does not rotate as a whole. Note the lines of
symmetry in both sections of the figure. Figure 2
PHYSICS
TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
35
eration
Ig
and the
required travel time
of seven hours,
the
acceleration length
is
66 km.)
With
no
need
for
aerody-
namic design,
the
vehicles
can be far
more roomy
and
comfortable than
the
typical earthbound commercial
jet.
Life
in the
colonies
The
key
statements
so far
have been
based
on
known facts,
on
calculations
that
can be
checked
and on
technology
whose costs
can be
estimated realistical-
ly.
The
discussion, however, would
be
sterile without some
speculations—
speculations that must,
of
course,
be
consistent with
the
known facts.
With
an
abundance
of
food
and
clean
electrical energy, controlled climates
and temperate weather, living condi-
tions
in the
colonies should
be
much
more pleasant than
in
most places
on
Earth.
For the
20-mile distances
of the
cylinder interiors, bicycles
and low-
speed electric vehicles
are
adequate.
Fuel-burning cars, powered aircraft
and
combustion heating
are not
needed;
therefore,
no
smog.
For
external travel,
the simplicity
of
engineless, pilotless
ve-
hicles probably means that individuals
and families will
be
easily able
to
afford
private space vehicles
for
low-cost trav-
el
to far
distant communities with
di-
verse cultures
and
languages.
The
"recreational vehicles"
of the
colonial
age
are
therefore likely
to be
simple
spacecraft, consisting
of
well furnished
pressure shells with little complexity
beyond
an
oxygen supply
and
with
much
the
same arrangement
of
kitchen
facilities
and
living space
as are
found
today
in our
travelling homes.
All Earth sports,
as
well
as new
ones,
are possible
in the
communities.
Skiing, sailing, mountain climbing (with
the gravity decreasing linearly
as the al-
titude increases)
and
soaring
are
exam-
ples.
As an
enthusiastic glider pilot,
I
have checked
the
question
of
thermal
scales:
The
soaring pilots
of the
coloni-
al
age
should find sufficient atmospher-
ic instability
to
provide them with lift.
At high altitudes, man-powered
flight—
a nearly impossible dream
on
Earth—
becomes easy.
A
special, slowly rotat-
ing agricultural cylinder with water
and
fish
can
have gravity
10~
2
or
10~
3
times
that
on
Earth
for
skin diving free
of
pressure-equalization problems. Noisy
or polluting sports, such
as
auto racing,
can easily
be
carried
out in one of the
cylinders
of the
external ring.
The self-sufficiency
of
space
com-
munities probably
has a
strong effect
on
government.
A
community
of
200
000
people, eager
to
preserve
its own
culture
and language,
can
even choose
to re-
main largely isolated. Free, diverse
so-
cial experimentation could thrive
in
such
a
protected, self-sufficient envi-
ronment.
If
we
drop
our
limitation
to
present
technology,
the
size
of a
community
could
be
larger.
One
foreseeable devel-
opment
is the use of
near-frictionless
(for example, magnetic) bearings
be-
tween
a
rotating cylinder
and its sup-
porting structure, which need
not be
spun.
For
eight tons
per
square meter
of surface density
and a
tensile strength
of
300 000 psi, R
would
be 16 km, the
total area would
50
000
km
2
, and the
population would
be
between five
mil-
lion
(low
density)
and 700
million
(the
ecological limit,
the
maximum popula-
tion that
can be
supported).
In Table
1 we see my
estimate
of the
earliest possible schedule
for
space colo-
nization, beginning with
a
model
com-
munity
in the
late
1980's.
From about
the year 2014,
I
assume
a
doubling time
of
six
years
for the
colonies; that
is, the
workforce
of a
"parent" colony could
build
a
"daughter" colony within that
time.
In
making these estimates
I
have
calculated that
the
first model commu-
nity would require
a
construction effort
of
42
tons
per
man-year, comparable
to
the effort
for
large-scale bridge building
on Earth. Full-size communities
at
high population density require
50
tons
per man-year,
and up to
5000 tons
per
man-year
for low
population density.
For comparison, automated mining
and
shipping
in
Australia
now
reaches
200
tons
per
man-year averaged over
a
town.
6
In
the
long
run,
space-colony
con-
struction
is
ideally suited
to
automa-
tion.
A
colony's structure consists
mainly
of
cables, fittings
and
window
panels
of
standard modular form
in a
pattern repeated thousands
of
times.
The assembly takes place
in a
zero-
gravity environment free
of the
vagaries
of weather.
By the
time that
the
colo-
nies
are
evolving
to low
population
den-
sity, therefore,
I
suspect that very
few
people will
be
involved
in
their
con-
struction. Most
of the
workforce will
probably
be
occupied
in
architecture,
landscaping, forestry, zoological plan-
ning, botany
and
other activities that
are nonrepetitive
and
require
a
sense
of
art
and
beauty.
Our
new
options
It
is
important
to
realize
the
enor-
mous power
of the
space-colonization
technique.
If we
begin
to use it
soon
enough,
and if we
employ
it
wisely,
at
least five
of the
most serious problems
now facing
the
world
can be
solved
without recourse
to
repression: bring-
ing every human being
up to a
living
standard
now
enjoyed only
by the
most
fortunate; protecting
the
biosphere
from damage caused
by
transportation
and industrial pollution; finding high-
quality living space
for a
world popula-
tion that
is
doubling every
35
years;
finding clean, practical energy sources;
preventing overload
of
Earth's heat
bal-
ance.
I hesitate somewhat
to
claim
for
space-colonization
the
ability
to
solve
one other problem,
one of the
most
ago-
nizing
of all: the
pain
and
destruction
caused
by
territorial wars. Cynics
are
sure that humanity will always choose
savagery even when territorial pressures
are much reduced. Certainly
the
mani-
acal wars
of
conquest have
not
been
ba-
sically territorial.
Yet I am
more hope-
ful;
I
believe
we
have begun
to
learn
a
little
bit in the
past
few
decades.
The
history
of the
past
30
years suggests
that warfare
in the
nuclear
age is
strongly, although
not
wholly, motivat-
ed
by
territorial conflicts; battles over
limited, nonextendable pieces
of
land.
From
the
viewpoint
of
international
arms control,
two
reasons
for
hope come
to mind.
We
already have
an
interna-
tional treaty banning nuclear weapons
from space,
and the
colonies
can
obtain
all
the
energy they could ever need from
clean solar power,
so the
temptations
presented
by
nuclear-reactor bypro-
ducts need
not
exist
in the
space
com-
munities.
To illustrate
the
power
of
space-colo-
nization
in a
specific, calculable situa-
Torque
(*)
_
Sun
Angular momentum of north cylinder
Force
Tension cable
,
Force
Force
t
Compression tower
Angular momentum of south cylinder
Force'
Torque
Force
and
torque diagram
for a
cylinder. Nondissipative static forces
are
used
to
precess
the
spin angular momenta,
so
that cylinder axes always point toward
the
Sun. Figure
3
3 6 PHYSICS
TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
tion, we trace the evolution of a worst-
case example: Suppose the present
population-increase
rate were to con-
tinue on Earth and in the space colo-
nies.
In that case the total human pop-
ulation would increase 20 000-fold in a
little over 500 years. Space-coloniza-
tion would absorb even so huge a
growth, as we shall see from our calcula-
tions.
The total volume of material needed
in a full-size community is 1.4 X 10
9
cubic meters, and the material available
in the asteroid belt (from which the
later communities will be built) is esti-
mated to be 4 X 10
17
cubic meters,
about one twenty-five hundredth the
volume of Earth. For a present world
population of 3.9 X 10
9
people and a
growth rate
7
of 1.98% per year (the
1965-71 average), the asteroidal materi-
al would last 500 years, corresponding
to a 20 000-fold population increase at
low
population density.
In figure 4, we see the development of
this worst-case problem. To hasten the
solution of that problem, the initial
space community population density is
taken as the ecological limit; the maxi-
mum number of people that can be sup-
ported with food grown within the com-
munities, with conventional agriculture.
Richard Bradfield has grown enough to
feed 72 people per hectare by the tech-
niques of double planting and multiple
cropping, and with the use of cuttings
for livestock feed. These results,
8
as
published and also as described to me
by Bradfield, were obtained in the
Phil-
lipines, which has only a nine-month
growing season and less than ideal
weather conditions. Calculations based
on his figures, but assuming an ideal
twelve-month season, indicate that the
colonies should be able to support 143
people per hectare with a diet of 3000
calories, 52 grams of usable protein and
4.3 pounds of total food per person per
day.
9
Much of the protein would come
from poultry and pork. The two main
cylinders of Model 1 should then be
able to support up to 10 800 people, and
the corresponding ecological limit for a
full-size community would be 20 million
people. At this limit, all the colonists
would have a high standard of living,
but in apartment-house living condi-
tions,
looking out over farmland. For a
community limit of
13-million
people,
the main cylinders could be kept free of
agriculture.
By about 2050, then, figure 4 indi-
cates that emigration to the colonies
could reverse the rise in Earth's popula-
tion, and that the acceleration of the so-
lution could be dramatically fast:
Within less than 30 years, Earth's popu-
lation could be reduced from a peak of
16.5 billion people to whatever stable
value is desired. I have suggested 1.2
billion as a possible optimum; it corre-
sponds to the year 1910 in Earth histo-
ry. The reduction in population densi-
ty in the space communities could be
equally rapid, and within another 40
years new construction could thin out
the communities to a stable density of
1.43 people per hectare, about one hun-
dredth of the ecological limit. The
total land area in the colonies would
then be more than three times that of
Earth.
We can hope that, in contrast to this
worst-case example, some progress
toward zero population growth
10
will be
made in the next 75 years. Any such
progress will hasten the solution, reduce
Earths population peak, and hasten the
day when the population densities on
Earth as well as in the colonies can be
reduced to an optimum value.
Building the first colony
A responsible proposal to begin the
construction of the first colony must be
based on a demonstration, in some de-
tail,
of one workable plan with realistic
cost estimates. I emphasize two points
about any such plan: The details pre-
sented should be thought of simply as
an existence proof of feasibility; and
many variations are possible. The op-
Table 3. Guideline Parameters for Transport Linear Accelerator
Acceleration
Average accelerating force
Maximum field
Bucket dry mass
Payload
Repetition rate
Transport rate
Buckets on accelerator
Sector length (accelerator)
Inductance per meter
Peak stored energy per meter
Maximum frequency
(LSM)*
Instantaneous length driven
Direct current in bucket coil
Peak current in
LSM*
Acceleration power
Ohmic
losses (feeders)
288
meters/sec
2
900
lbs
10 000 gauss
5 kg
9 kg
1/sec
750 tons/day
8
50 meters
0.6 microHy
10.4 KJ
2500 Hz
2 meters
75 X
10
3
amp-turns
136 X 10
3
amps
40
MW
15 MW
' LSM: linear synchronous motor
Table 4. Estimated Cost of Building Space Colonies (in 1972 dollars)
Item
Launch vehicles
Transport
E
—•
L
5
People E
—
L
5
Transport
E
- •
M
Equipment for Moon
Equipment for
L
5
Machines and tools
(L
5
)
Salaries
(L
r
,)
Salaries (Earth)
Totals
Model 1 Model 2
Unit cost
0.3 X 10
9
425/lb
1000/Ib
1000/1b
400/1
b
180/lb
625/lb
50
000/man-year
30 000/man-year
Total (in $10
9
)
0.9
8.5
2.2
6.6
2.4
1.2
1.1
0.6
7.2
30.7
($5.1 X
10
9
/yr)
Unit cost
0.5 X 10
5
250/lb
500/lb
500/1
b
400/lb
180/lb
625/lb
(25%
on Earth)
(30 000/man-year)
Total (in $10
9
)
1.5
11.0
8.8
2.2
1.8
2.0
2.8
2.0
2.0
34.1*
(4.3 X
10
9
/yr*)
'The
cost saving due to the presence of Model 1 can be divided as follows: production,
25
000lbs/man-year;
workforce, 4000 people; transport
costs,
$250/lb. The saving over the eight years needed to complete the colony is thus a total of $200 X 10
9
.
PHYSICS
TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
37
timum
design and course of action can
only be decided on after study and con-
sultation among experts in a number of
fields.
The nominal values for the first
model colony are taken as: construc-
tion force, 2000 people; population,
10 000; total mass, 500 000 tons. When
the design and cost analysis are done in
detail for the entire enterprise, the need
to fit a budget may force some reduc-
tion in size. The initial estimates have
been aimed at holding the cost equal to
that of one project we have already car-
ried through: Apollo. The choice of
10 000 as a target population ensures
that, even with some reduction, Model 1
will be large enough to obtain econo-
mies of scale and to serve as an effective
industrial base for the construction of
Model 2. A much reduced colonization
project would be little more than a re-
named space station, perhaps able to
maintain itself but incapable of build-
ing the larger models that are necessary
if the program is ultimately to support
itself.
It is an essential feature of the
colonization project that Earth should
no longer have to support it after the
first two or three stages.
Ultimately, colonization could take
place in the entire sphere, 3 X 10
17
km
2
in area, that surrounds the Sun at the
distance we have evolved to prefer (the
so-called "Dyson sphere"). For the
Rotary pellet launcher
The
rotary launcher
is
assumed
to be a
symmetric two-arm propeller-like
device,
running
at
constant
speed,
with launching
arms
of
ten-meter
radius.
Mass
Rotation rate
Tip
speed
(escape velocity)
Power
10 tons
2300 rpm
2400
m/sec
1600
horsepower
The
transfer rate
per
launcher
is
3250
tons
per
year
for the
transfer
of 5-gm
pel-
lets,
assuming
a 25%
duty
cycle. The
strength-to-mass ratio
for the
launcher
is
within
the
range attainable
by
boron-fila-
ment
technology:
An
aluminum matrix
containing boron grown
on
tungsten cores
is
calculated
to
have
a
yield stress
of
322 000 psi and
average density
4.1, so
that
p/T
= 135 X
10~
6
Here
p is the
density
and
fthe tension
in
MKS
units.
For
uniform
stress,
the
ratio
of arm
radii
at the
base
and the tip (r, and
r
2
)is
log
rjr,
=
(p/47V
where
v is the
escape
velocity.
For
r-
[
/r
2
less than
50,
pi
T
must
be
less than
2.08
X 10"
6
.
first colony it is probably best to choose
a particular point on that sphere, within
easy range of both Earth and Moon, not
so close as to be eclipsed often, and
preferably stable against displacements
in all three coordinates. The
L4
and
L5
Lagrange
libration
points satisfy all
these conditions. They have the fur-
ther advantage of forming only a very
shallow effective-potential well.
11
Earth, Moon, Sun and the colony
form a restricted four-body gravita-
tional problem, for which the full
solu-.
tion has only been worked out within
the past several years.
12
The stable
motion is a quasielliptical orbit, of large
dimensions, about L5. The maximum
excursions in arc and radius are several
tenths of the Earth-Moon distance.
On the stable orbit there is room for
several thousand colonies; a long time
will pass before colonization can fill so
big an orbit.
Cost minimization
There are several key problems in-
volved here, each of which appears to
yield to an efficient solution in princi-
ple:
reducing freight-shipment cost
from the Earth to L5, the colony site;
minimizing the mass needed from
Earth; designing a device for low-cost
transfer of materials from the Moon to
L
5
.
The first problem was considered by
Robert Wilson (NASA), Eric Hannah
and George Hazelrigg (Princeton) at a
meeting held 9 and 10 May at Princeton
(A Proceedings of this meeting will be
published). Their conclusion was that
the best method during the
1980's
will
probably be conventional chemical
rockets—specifically,
the high-quality
engines already being developed for the
space shuttle. Among several varia-
tions possible, the common feature was
reusability, and the cost estimates for
shipment varied from $190 to $400 per
pound, in 1972 dollars. The cost sum-
mary table (Table 4) therefore assumes
$425 per pound.
To reduce the mass needed from
Earth, most of the repetitive structural
members (aluminum) and window pan-
els (glass) must be produced at
L
5
from
lunar material. A further, important
saving is made by getting 89% of the
mass of needed water from oxygen in
the plentiful lunar-surface oxides,
bringing only 11% of the water mass as
liquid hydrogen from Earth. Of the
500 000-ton total mass (see Table 2) for
the Model 1 colony, 98% can be ob-
tained from the Moon. The elements
most needed are aluminum, titanium,
silicon and oxygen. Lunar surface soil
is usable for agriculture, with the addi-
tion of nitrates and small amounts of
trace elements. The remaining 10 000
tons must come from the Earth.
To bring the total cost within practi-
cal limits, we must develop a low-cost
method for transporting raw materials
from the Moon to the construction site.
The discussion of transport methods
should be taken as an existence proof
rather than as a detailed design. There
may very well be better methods than
those I have considered; however, it is
enough to show two solutions that ap-
pear to be workable. Both use the two
great advantages of the lunar environ-
ment: an excellent vacuum and a very
low escape velocity, about
1.5
miles per
sec,
less than one quarter of the escape
velocity from Earth. To bring a kilo-
gram to
L
5
from the Moon takes less
than 5% of the energy needed to take a
kilogram from Earth.
Both methods assume electric power
from a conventional steam-electric
power plant that uses solar energy, and
both assume that the system runs only
during the lunar day, the night being
used for scheduled maintenance, crew
rest and possibly materials processing.
I have also assumed another factor of
two lost to system breakdowns. Overall
then, each system is assumed to be run-
ning only one week in four.
The first method, called "RPL" for
rotary pellet launcher, is a symmetric,
two-arm propeller-like device, running
at constant speed. (See box on page 38
for description). To transfer 500 tons
in six years, about 26 such RPL's would
be needed, for a total power of 32 MW.
Precise steering is carried out by a lin-
ear electromagnetic deflection-plate
system after the launching, to hold
down the pellet dispersion and permit
easy collection.
The alternative method, called
"TLA" for transport linear accelerator,
uses the technology of dynamic magnet-
ic levitation and the linear synchronous
motor. The TLA is a recirculating sys-
tem of small, passive vehicles (buckets),
each having no moving parts but con-
taining superconducting coils. The
bucket accelerates a 9-kg payload to es-
cape speed along a magnetic-levitation,
linear-synchronous track. Deceleration
then releases the payload, the bucket
slows to a moderate speed, and is recir-
culated to receive another payload.
Table 3 shows some guideline parame-
ters.
The mass estimate is 1500 tons, of
which about 80% is in power-generation
and power-handling equipment. In six
years,
running
25%
of the time, the TLA
can transport over 300 times its own
weight. (For a short bibliography of
early work on the possibilities of elec-
tromagnetic launching, before the de-
velopment of dynamic magnetic levita-
tion, see reference 13.)
Both RPL and TLA may have even-
tual applications as high-throughput,
energetically efficient reaction motors,
running on solar power and able to use
any kind of asteroidal debris as reaction
mass.
They could propel very large
payloads, in the million-ton range or
38 PHYSICS
TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
1975
2150
Effectiveness of space colonization in solving a hypothetical
"worst
case " population-growth
problem.
The case considered assumes no reduction of population growth rate either on Earth
or in the space colonies. Here
P
e
is the population of Earth,
P
s
that of space, and
A^lA^
the
ratio of land area in space (all usable) to total land area of Earth. Both
P
e
and
P
s
/A^
reach sta-
ble,
relatively low values. Changes within wide limits in the assumed input numbers do not af-
fect the reaching of a stable solution, nor do they affect the final stable values of
P
e
and
P
s
l
A$.
This figure is an example of the power of space-colonization, not a prediction. Figure 4
higher, between the asteroid belt and
the
L5
site.
The Model 1 colony will be too small
to carry out a wide variety of manufac-
turing processes, but it can perform
those tasks that are energy intensive,
not labor intensive, and that will pro-
duce a large return in total tonnage.
One example is the production of alu-
minum by the Hall process. An in-
stalled capacity of 40 MW is enough to
produce 20 000 tons of aluminum in two
years,
for the exostructure of Model 1.
Another example is the separation of
oxygen from the lunar oxides to com-
bine with hydrogen brought from
Earth. (With 50 000 tons of water,
Model 1 can have lush vegetation as
well as substantial streams and small
lakes).
In contrast, small, low-mass
parts are best brought from Earth.
The later colonies, perhaps beginning
with Model 3, will use asteroidal mate-
rial,
which is rich in hydrocarbons as
well as in metals. We can speculate
that, relatively early in the development
of the colonies, the economics of freight
transport will probably dictate that the
"up"
shipments from Earth will consist
only of people and labor-intensive,
miniaturized products such as comput-
ers and calculators. The "down" ship-
ping costs may be lower because of the
possibility of atmospheric braking. Be-
tween colonies, all shipping and travel
costs should be very low. For Model 1,
the project cost is summarized in Table
4.
For comparison, the Apollo project
cost about 33 billion (1972) dollars.
We can also see in Table 4 that the
economic payoff from the construction
of the first community will come quick-
ly, during construction of the second.
That payoff will be in the form of trans-
port costs saved because tools and fab-
ricated structures will be made from
lunar material at Community 1 rather
than on Earth. The first colony can ap-
parently pay for itself in one or two
years,
and, by its presence, can keep the
annual cost of building Community
2—with
its 100 000 to 200 000 people—
at about the same level as for Commu-
nity 1. After that, construction costs
for models 3, 4 and so on, should taper
off as space-based industry becomes
stronger, and as the wide range of
chemical elements in the asteroids are
used.
We can speculate that the second or
third colony may begin to pay back its
construction cost in additional
ways,
for
example by the manufacture of high-
strength single crystals
14
in the zero-
gravity, high-vacuum environment that
surrounds it, and by the manufacture of
titanium products.
To follow the economics as far as
Model 3 would be too speculative; its
costs to Earth will mainly be those of
transporting its one to two million in-
habitants to L5. Its earlies possible
completion date is estimated at just
after the turn of the century (28 years
forward in time; going back the same
number of years brings us to the era of
the V2 rocket, more than ten years be-
fore the first artificial
satellite).
Around the year 2000, a fully reusable
chemical rocket system could transport
payloads to
L
5
at a cost of about $100
per pound (again, in 1972 dollars). A
prospective colonist could therefore
save enough money
(one
or two years'
salary) to emigrate with his family of
three. The near certainty of continued
advances in propulsion systems
suggests that the actual costs will be
lower.
By the middle years of the next cen-
tury, and possibly
earlier,
production
costs at
L5
should be lower than on
Earth. My reasons for this belief are
that:
• the asteroid belt is a rich source of
raw materials, already exposed and dif-
ferentiated.
• transport from the belt to L5 can be
done in a way analogous to ocean
freight on Earth; that is, in very large
units,
with low fuel costs and very small
crews.
In space, it may be most practi-
cal to eliminate the freighter hulls en-
tirely. A TLA-type reaction motor can
run on free solar power and transport
an entire asteroid to
L
5
,
perhaps with
no crew at all.
• food-raising costs, production costs
and shipping costs among the com-
munities should all be lower than on
Earth because of ideal growing condi-
tions,
proximity of farms to consumers,
availability of unlimited solar power
and the convenience of zero-gravity and
high-vacuum environments for produc-
tion and transportation.
If we are so prodigal as to run
through the entire material of the aster-
oid belt in the next 500 years, we can
even gain another 500 years by using up
the moons of the outer planets. Long
before then, I hope we will have slowed
the growth of the human population.
And I feel sure that long before then a
modified version of a space community
will have travelled to a nearby star.
I am left with the desire to communi-
cate two aspects of this work more com-
pletely. On the one hand. I would like
to display for review more of the details
of calculations and references than is
possible here. And on the other hand, I
am acutely aware of the need for discus-
sion outside our own group of physics-
oriented people. This work should be
discussed and debated as widely as pos-
sible,
by people with a range of techni-
cal and artistic talents, and by people
who claim no special talent beyond the
ability to work hard for a worthwhile
goal. I hope I have conveyed at least a
little of the sense of excitement that I
have enjoyed over the past few years as
each serious problem has appeared to
yield to a solution, as well as
how
much
more remains to be done and how much
PHYSICS TODAY/SEPTEMBER 1974
39
FROM
SCHOTT
PRODUCTION
Finished
Color Filters
MPT DELIVERY AND HIGH QUALITY
Schott's new color filter glass finishing
operation
is
now on-line
. . .
adding the serv-
ice
of
an in-house finishing facility
to
Schott's
well-earned reputation for precisely-controlled
color glass melts.
The
newest concepts
in
filter finishing, including special equipment
designed expressly
for
Schott, now insure the
best and most competitive product available.
No longer must the designer choose be-
tween standard, readily available filters
and
Schott's quality glass.
The
purchasing agent
now
has a
competitive full service source,
from glass
to
finished filter. And, with design
and purchasing well
in
hand, the project man-
ager
has
that much more time
to
devote
to
profitability.
In short, this new approach offers some-
thing for everyone. Give us a call and see what
it can do for you.
" We made the
art a
science.
Now we've made
it a
modern manufacturing process."
SCHOTT OPTICAL GLASS
INC.
DURYEA, PENNSYLVANIA 18642
(717) 457-7485 TELEX 837423
Circle No. 20 on Reader Service Card
40
PHYSICS TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974
need there
is for
good ideas
and
hard
work.
*
* *
For private communications leading
to
ref-
erences,
I
thank Donald
Gault,
Barry Royce,
Richard Johnson, George Hazelrigg
and
John Breakwell.
And it is a
special plea-
sure
to
thank those who encouraged
me to
continue this work
in the
years when
it
was
little known, particularly George
Pimentel,
Freeman Dyson, Brian O'Leary, Roman
Smoluchowski, Richard Feynman and John
Tukey.
I
am also grateful
to
Michael Phil-
lips
of the
Point Foundation, which
sup-
ported
the
first public meeting
on
this
subject.
References
1.
G. A.
Hool,
W. S.
Kinne, Movable and
Long Span Steel Bridges, McGraw-Hill,
New York, (1943), page 328; D. B. Stein-
man,
A
Practical Treatise
on
Suspen-
sion Bridges, John Wiley,
New
York
(1929),
page 236.
2.
S. F.
Singer, Scientific American,
Sep-
tember 1970, page 174.
3.
"Meteoroid
Environment
Model—1969
(Near Earth
to
Lunar Surface)," NASA
SP-8013.
4.
G.
Latham,
J.
Dorman,
F.
Duennebier,
M. Ewing,
D.
Lammlein,
Y.
Nakamura,
"Moonquakes, Meteorites
and the
State
of
the
Lunar Interior,"
and
"Lunar
Seismology,"
in
Abstracts
of
the Fourth
Lunar Science Conference, 1973, Lunar
Science Institute, 3303 NASA Road
1,
Houston, Texas 77058.
5.
R. E.
McCrosky, "Distributions
of
Large
Meteoric Bodies," Smithsonian Astro-
physical Observatory Special Report No.
280.
6.
K.
MacLeish, "Australia's Wild,"
in
Na-
tional Geographic 143, no.
2,168,
(1973).
7.
"1970 World Population Data Sheet,"
Population Reference Bureau
Inc,
1755
Massachusetts Ave,
N.
W., Washington,
D.C. 20036.
8.
R.
Bradfield, "Multiple
Cropping—
Hope
for
Hungry Asia,"
in
Reader's Di-
gest, October 1972, page 217.
9.
F. M.
Lappe, Diet
for a
Small Planet,
Ballantine Books, New Vork, (1971).
10.
"The
Limits
of
Development," Report
by the Systems Dynamics Group, Massa-
chusetts Institute
of
Technology (1972),
Club of Rome, Geneva.
11.
W. H. Michael Jr, "Considerations of the
Motion
of a
Small Body
in the
Vicinity
of
the
Stable Libration Points
of the
Earth-Moon System," NASA
TR-160
(1963).
12.
R.
Kolenkiewicz,
L.
Carpenter, "Stable
Periodic Orbits About
the
Sun-Per-
turbed Earth-Moon Triangular Points,"
AIAA
Journal 6, no.
7,
1301 (1968); A. A.
Kamel,
"Perturbation Theory Based
on
Lie Transforms
and its
Application
to
the Stability
of
Motion Near Sun-Per-
turbed Earth-Moon Triangular Libra-
tion Points," NASA
CR-1622,
August
1970.
13.
A. C. Clarke,
J.
Brit. Interplanetary
Soc.
9,261(1950).
14.
H. C.
Gatos,
A. F. Witt, "Crystal Growth
Studies
on
Skylab," MIT News Release,
14
May 1974.
°

Discussion

Tap the paper where you want to comment
Gerard Kitchen O’Neill (1927–1992) was a Princeton physicist whose scientific training began at seventeen, when he joined the U.S. Navy and learned to maintain radar equipment. He studied physics at Swarthmore, earned his doctorate at Cornell, and joined Princeton in 1954. He later helped build one of the first electron colliders at Stanford, where two magnetic rings guided beams of electrons into head-on collisions. In 1969 he gave his introductory physics students a different problem. What would it take to build a permanent home in orbit? Five years later, he published his own answer in these pages. His design placed entire towns inside rotating cylinders, where the inner wall would feel like the ground underfoot. ![](https://i.imgur.com/BULsiHJ.png) *Gerard O'Neill* Konstantin Tsiolkovsky (1857–1935) was a nearly deaf, largely self-taught schoolteacher in provincial Kaluga, Russia, who worked out the theoretical foundations of spaceflight decades before anyone could build the hardware. His 1903 paper derived what is now called the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, $\Delta v = v_e \ln\left(\frac{m_0}{m_1}\right)$, which still governs every launch today. The “hangup” O’Neill mentions is the assumption that colonies must sit on planets. Tsiolkovsky had sidestepped it by the turn of the century. His novel Beyond the Planet Earth (begun 1896, published 1920) describes free-floating orbital habitats that spin for artificial gravity, run on sunlight and grow food in greenhouses ![](https://i.imgur.com/MlmhwSS.png) *Konstantin Tsiolkovsky* ### Spaceflight in September 1974 Only about 73 people had ever been to space, 41 Americans and 32 Soviets. All but one were men (Valentina Tereshkova, 1963), and no third country had flown anyone. Twelve men had walked on the Moon, the last of them in December 1972 (Apollo 17). Apollos 18–20 had been cancelled, the Saturn V had flown for the final time in 1973, and NASA’s budget had fallen from over 4% of federal spending in 1966 to about 1%. The longest anyone had lived in space was 84 days, set by the final Skylab crew, who came home in February 1974. Skylab itself now sat empty in orbit. The Soviets were flying small Salyut stations for stays of a few weeks. The Space Shuttle, on which O’Neill’s cost estimates lean heavily, had been approved in 1972 but existed only on paper; it would not fly until 1981. **Why two?** The colony sits at L5, a stable point in the Moon's orbit 60° behind the Moon, so it circles Earth once a month and, along with Earth, circles the Sun once a year. To keep its axis aimed at the Sun it must therefore turn 360° per year, about 1° per day. A single spinning cylinder resists this. It is a giant gyroscope whose angular momentum $L = I\omega$ holds its axis fixed relative to the stars, and turning it at rate $\Omega$ takes a continuous torque $\tau = \Omega \times L$, which would mean burning propellant forever. Two cylinders spinning in opposite directions cancel out: $L_{total} = 0$. Linked at the ends, each supplies the torque the other needs, so the pair can track the Sun using only internal forces and no fuel. ![](https://i.imgur.com/YVDxmps.gif) **Why four miles?** O'Neill assumes the cylinder is held together by ordinary steel cable, no stronger than what suspension bridges used in the 1920s (a working stress of 150,000 psi). He picks this on purpose, to show that nothing in the design depends on materials that don't exist yet. Think of a suspension bridge cable. Make the span longer and the cable gets heavier, so more of its strength goes into holding up itself and less is left for the roadway. Past a certain span, the cable can only carry its own weight. The steel bands wrapped around the cylinder face the same problem. Spinning to produce 1 g makes the bands "weigh" something too, and that self-load grows with radius as $p g R$. With O'Neill's steel, the bands could support only themselves at $R \approx 13$ km. At $R = 3.2$ km, about a quarter of their strength is already used up this way. So four miles is not a hard limit. It is the point where each extra acre of land starts costing disproportionately more steel, which is why O'Neill calls the figure "somewhat arbitrary" and notes that stronger materials would allow much larger cylinders. O’Neill was writing just two years after the last Apollo landing, and his claim rests on the 382 kg of rock and soil those missions brought back between 1969 and 1972. The samples showed two main terrains. The bright highlands are anorthosite, a rock rich in the mineral plagioclase and roughly 25–30% aluminum oxide by weight. The dark maria are basalts, some of which (notably at the Apollo 11 and 17 sites) contain around 10% titanium dioxide, locked in the mineral ilmenite, $\mathrm{FeTiO_3}$. Lunar soil is also about 40–45% oxygen by weight, bound up in these oxides and silicates. The big surprise came after O’Neill’s death. In 1974 the Moon was thought to be completely dry, which is why his Table 2 lists 5,400 tons of liquid hydrogen to be shipped from Earth and combined with lunar oxygen to make water. Lunar Prospector found hints of hydrogen at the poles in 1998, and in 2009 Chandrayaan-1 and NASA’s LCROSS impact confirmed water ice in permanently shadowed polar craters. **Longerons.** The word comes from aircraft design, where a longeron is a structural member running the length of a fuselage. Here they are steel cables running the length of the cylinder, from one end cap to the other. Their job is to stop the air from blowing the ends off. The atmosphere inside pushes outward on each end cap with enormous force, equivalent to the weight of roughly 330 million tons on Earth for a cylinder of this size. The longerons are stretched between the caps and hold them together, like the strings on a parcel. Spread evenly around the cylinder, the steel needed for this works out to a layer about 16 cm thick. The circumferential bands do the complementary job, resisting the outward push on the curved wall, like the hoops on a barrel. They have the harder task, since they also carry the spin-induced weight of the soil, of the longerons, and of themselves. ![](https://i.imgur.com/V7cvYWJ.png) If you want to explore a 3d visualization of a O’Neill Cylinder go to https://oneill.joaobatalha.com/ ![](https://i.imgur.com/YVDxmps.gif) How size shapes the environment. Gravity doesn’t depend on size because the spin rate is simply adjusted to give 1 g at the rim: a small cylinder spins fast, a large one slowly (once every 114 seconds at $R = 3200$ m). What size does change is cost and how Earth-like the place feels. A smaller cylinder needs far less steel, but spins faster and holds less air. A larger one has a gentler rotation and a deeper sky, at the price of much more structure. **Why the sky can still be blue in a O’Neill Cylinder** “Atmospheric depth” is the amount of air you look through. On Earth the sky is blue because sunlight scatters off the miles of air overhead. In the cylinder the air is only as deep as the cylinder is wide, and it thins toward the axis, where there is no apparent gravity to compress it. Looking straight up from the ground to the land on the far side, you see through about two thirds as much air as from sea level on Earth. That is the same as standing at 3300 m, roughly the altitude of Cusco in Peru, where the sky is still plainly blue. In a much smaller cylinder the “sky” would be too thin to scatter much light and would look dark. **Keeping it lit and temperate.** A habitat in space faces two linked problems: it needs natural sunlight for an Earth-like day, and it must not overheat in constant sun or freeze in shadow. O'Neill's answer to both is the set of large mirrors outside the windows. Opening them brings in daylight and heat, closing them brings on night and lets the cylinder cool, so the length of the day sets the climate. This passage explains why the resulting temperature swings would be gentle. The soil, structure and air together store as much heat as $3 \times 10^8$ tons of water, a lake roughly 10 km across and 4 m deep. If sunlight had to warm all of that mass evenly, the temperature would climb only 0.7 °C per hour. In practice only the air and the top few centimetres of soil respond within a day, exactly as on Earth, so mornings warm up faster than that. The colony gets a natural-feeling cycle of warm afternoons and cool nights, with the deep mass acting as a buffer against extremes. Depiction of the agricultural Cylinders ![](https://i.imgur.com/nQ4iDjw.jpeg) O’Neill works backward from demand. He assumes 100,000 residents each using 120 kW, for a total of 12,000 MW of electricity. The supply is sunlight collected by a mirror the size of the cylinder’s end cap. Power is area times intensity: the cap’s area is $\pi R^2 \approx 3.2 \times 10^7\ \mathrm{m^2}$, and sunlight near Earth delivers about 1.35 kW per square metre. That gives roughly 43,000 MW, which O’Neill rounds down to 36,000, presumably to allow for losses. A steam turbine converts about a third of that heat to electricity, which matches the demand. The 120 kW figure is generous. An American today uses about 9 kW, slightly less than in 1974, and a German or Japanese about 4 kW. **Shielding from radiation** In this paper O’Neill underestimated how much radiation shielding a colony needs. He assumed the air, soil and steel already in the design would be enough, the way the atmosphere protects us on Earth. That is roughly true for the giant final cylinder, but not for the small first colony, which holds little air and has large open windows. Cosmic rays are so energetic that a thin layer of material does not stop them. You need several tons of mass over every square metre, in every direction, comparable to the 10 tons per square metre of air above us on Earth. A NASA study one year later worked out what that means for a colony of 10,000 people. It called for a layer of lunar soil 1.7 m thick around the habitat, bringing the total mass to 10 million tons, 95% of it shielding. O’Neill had budgeted 500,000 tons. The open windows were replaced by angled “chevron” mirrors that double as radiation shields, bouncing sunlight in while blocking the rays **The Apollo seismic network** Apollo astronauts left seismometers at five landing sites, four of which ran as a network until NASA switched them off in 1977. With no atmosphere to burn up meteoroids and no wind or oceans to add noise, the Moon is an ideal impact detector: the network recorded about 1,700 meteoroid strikes, giving O’Neill a direct measure of how often large ones arrive. **The Prairie Network** A set of 16 automatic camera stations across the American Midwest, run by the Smithsonian from 1964 to 1975, that photographed bright meteors each night. His point is that three independent methods (spacecraft sensors, lunar seismometers and sky cameras) agree, and together they imply that a one-ton meteoroid would hit a colony only about once in a million years.